! " !# $ %
& # '( #
)*+ ,- .+% / & # / 0- 1 $
231 .+% 0 1
4 % .+% 0 0" 231 %
5,678 9:# ;< $1 => ( # 3*
# 0 ** ;< 5$ ?+% *@*> A 4- B CD4
*- #
! " # $ % # & ' # ( ) * + , -& # ( .* . % / % "# - $.0 ! $.. 1
!2 ! 3 4 $ % # !-& 5 6& 78#9* :;
.
< = ! $. 4 $ % #
. ! - " -1 > 4 * !8 * ? ; $.0 1@& A1B1 5 1 B =
Prediction Markets
Information Markets
C
*) D.= < E1 "F*1 5 (* !8 *
$.0 1(F@"# )* + ! * ,-1 !*1G $.0 < # HI $
.* $.. J0 1 ! &0,F@
KFLM N >G (*0 ! < E- G ! ! . > ..@ ? E>* 3)* +
OPQ &ORQ "# ! 6
.& A1-& S (# ! 1@&
( # J0 71 6 T U V ? F (# 5
/$
3
S . & ! 1 W " # $. 0 "F- ! F(# ! 16
& . " Y 5 7. % / % (# J0
B
(# . /$
$ ?; 7<1 X .U
S .& ! 1W 7
/$
7. % * / % ! 1 W & . 1 #
! -& 5 J
< ! 1 F 8 ! 8 *
/ % & . Z 6 ! ( # J. [ , -& . 1* \ ! "# Z6 N 7
(# ]E & "# ^ [
$.0 ! ,@ 7$.6 ! > (6 !1F8 (*0 ! "# .Z6
16 ' #
.[ ! B = J0 _6 ! F- 7$.6! %G 41W ! ? ; "# _6 J0 9* S .& A1-& < F = S "# (# N&
: ` <1 1 a * ( 7 /$
"F-
S ! . 6 ! 6 1 @& ( # A1 * 5 G
( # 5 . 6 B = & " # b K * c a @
" F - \ ! " #
%
. <1 1 a * ( - < F = < F =
L ^ [ . & 5 1 _ 6 J0 9 * _ 6 ( L 7 ( # 5 < " F - ! " 6 9 * J1 . .6 $.0 ^ [ .& 5 .[ < F = E# .[ ! 6 d FB 1! 7$.6 ! %G eV ! . !@1
. F *
. / % 7
\ > 4 J0 1 1 [ ! *1 ,-& f J0 A1-& < F = 1[ & "#
!#& ! . > ! #1 5
boolean
S ? ; ! .&
(* N 7$.0 < # HI 4= !@ ? ; #
& 16 _L . < # HI ! "# -& .U < (# 5
E # . *1 < " a = ( # 5 " F - " a = .6 $.0 .U
.[ J1 ! (# "> J1 ! (6 7.Z6 ; $. " 6 5 " # : F ! g > " # _ L : E - Security
H
& &.V . .Z6 (*0 A1-& & .*1 & ! ( a = !1F8 J1M 7.
7"# 1[ 1# J !L \= W ! 8*0 "# $.6 _L :E- J0 S (# 716 .[ A1-& < F = ? ; G ! "# E
.+* B \= W 1L* !B "F- .&
. $ @ J ! ! " # ( 6 J1 &. V ! g > ( . : =$
\ = W . & . *. E Z 6 . 1 [ ! F - < E * ! \ = W
8 . <1 E - 16 !L N (* 1# ! 1 ! "#
& - % A1 -& &
( 6 3. ! K F ` (6 . <1E- 6&
J ( - . Z 6 G ? ; " a = . J.6 J (- &
/$
"F- < #0 J.6 J (- Z6 & & "# bK* ca
/ $
\= W G 7"# $.6 (L & h#1
Z6 & <1E-
h #1 " a =
"F- . *1 >i
J1M 71 .1[ "E; N1# "a = . 7jf Z6 &
$ ;.= " (* & . " /$
"%G J1 . 1# /$ :-.= & .*16 J (- & + ! a = \= W & !g> G & .*16
L
Z6 & "a =&
(6 . ! "a = = k 1G
!g> .6 &
7" &. V 6 J&. $1 a Z 6 A1 * ( L J ! J $ @
! 6 1@&
boolean .& n
? G ? ; . $.i E# V 9* !g>
.*1 G & . % / % $.0 "# +F "a = A1*
1[ $1Ua Z6 A1*
n
n 7.6 7. .Z6 ( a = $1a !1F8 &
J1 (*0 ! .Z6 (* "# 3Y :F "6
4.- & jl m* ! 1 ! J +F ( a = !1F8
.6 := : - E# V G.i n Va !g> & 6 ! 6 1[ J 9 * 7"# om ` - J & 1# !g> 5 ! 8*0 ( 6 J ! 8 ! . * [ ! J + 60 & 4 UUV .6 Y $.6 3 8* "- !8 * & . L "- 16
OCQ & ORQ . .p D.= ! G 3 8*
1 * $. 6 ( L ( * [ #!( !g> & om 61 * ! 3 * ! .Z6
# J \= W 1#
Permutation Betting Market
q
.[ (*0 ! . > .Z6 1* LK @ .Z6 +F ? ; "# " - 5 $. "6 ..* \ 5 S (*
.Z6 \#
n
1#\# !U > 5 (* \ & 1 "#
E # ( * " # 3Y & . * A1 -& J + ( * " a =
n!
" a = ! " # J 6 9 * . ! ( * ( a = ! 1 F 8 . *1 J . 6 o m OHQ a& ! . Z 6 ! g > . J 1 [
*
" a = & J1 ^ [ J \ = W 1 # #! ( ! g > \= W >U : - "a = >U : -r "a = &
>U
: - "a = s #
(L %* 5 G ? ; . <1E- $.6 (L Z6 5 F>- .*1 $ / $
]E
b K * c a <1 1 a * ( - S ( # 5 . [
(L _6 . . <1E- Z6 f
/$
%
.*1 \= W 7"#
7$.6 t Z6 J / % 41W & . " /$
$.
. . <1E- : 1! . Z6 \= W 7
>U : -r "a =
G.i & .*$.6 (L "LK @ & . Z6 ! (* ! & (*0 3. (6 J "%@ !g> E# V
J "#
!1F8 .Z6 J
Y > J " - J 5
+F (* !E !M ^ [ ..* 5 ! . _L .*1 ! .0 "# ! "# +F ..* !M h#1 * !E G - "#
s
6 ! 6 *1 Z6 A1*& .Z6 A1* 7 U- J !1F8 h#1 ! !E + x
..* . J L* !
(b, x, Y )
G - .*$.6 _L
Y
Betting on Permutation
Divisible
Indivisible
Subset Betting
R
•
-
y
! E X
! 1 F 8 . . * + . J L * ! (b, X, y)
•
.*G
"# Z6 N
b
Z6 A1* & !( u1@ J . J "%@ !g> ! "# $.6 " X OHQ ,@ J := : - >U : - "a = !1F8 .Z6 \= W
: -r "a = !g> ! "# $.6 $ J L* OqQ ,@ & "# !F@.M
EUkc 1Ka
!( u1@ c
c>
v ! !+ 7"#
NP-Complete
( !* >U
:-.= ! .. 1@ $.6 Fw 1 ! !LF ! F 1Ka
$ J L* !g> ^ [ "a = 5 ! "# $.6 $ % # $. .* .6 & "#
NP-Hard !*
"# %W \= W 1# !+ _L ! 16
\= W 1# ! ( a = .*1 EUkc 1Ka J1M NP-Hard ! g > J \ U 7j K / " > * ! ( a =
" # % W
"#
K . . * Y . . * 5 ! . J L * Z 6 ! ! 16 _L
N
b
& 1 .1[
(b, x, y) 41W
y
% @ . Z 6 ! Z6 7 U- 1 ! "G .1[ -
(* !E (
x ..*
(* !E ! "# .6 om OHQ ,@ a& J "# Z6
< = & J !1F8 J .* %@ .Z6 J J "%@ !g> ! "# $.6 $ J L* OHQ < = .# 9* ! $ #
7
> U : - r " a = & > U : - " a = 7. Z 6 A1 * "#
NP-Complete
5 7 %@ .Z6 J "%@ !g> T- := J1 "# ! !@1 3. J J L* ?* = EU 1Ka 5 J . \a @ !g>
$ # EU 1Ka 5 ! $.6 $ J L* OHQ "# EU 1Ka 1@&
.* :F 1[ +F !g> Pair Betting
P
! 1 F 8 . Z 6 W [ " a = 7. 6 o m OqQ ! ! *
K . Z 6
! # 41 W ! Z 6 7 U - J ! " # 1 w 5 ! 1 F 8 ! " #
]E b
& "G .1[ -
y
!E x
..* . ! "#
(b, x, y)
"# Z6
J "%@ !g> ! 16 e !1F8 J !@1 : - J $ #
OqQ . 6 ! F @. M J : = : - > U : - r " a = J J L* & 16 <.
xVW
! * 5 41W! !g> ! "# :=$ $.
5 J1 S m [ ! * ! ( , @ F i F &0 " # ! > u1 @ ! 1 6 $
l. , . U J F x V W u1 @
[ B 4 .U ! a = \= W 1# J !L !g>
"#
(xi , yi )
.1* -
.* (@&
yi
J + xi
19 "# $.6 # )* ..* ! . A ! @& M ) !
"F>- $.6 t m[ ! * $ % # ! "# $.6 $ J L* OqQ "G
1Ka 5 ,@ F := !F@.M J J1 )* !g> :Ek . ! 2 \ = W u1 @ 1 @& ! g > J 5 M m [
! 1 ! . u * (6 . .*1 \= W
0 !+ !g>
.6 "E; "a = . N1#
& !1F8 .Z6 !L 1# J. !g> J1 "# ! !@1 ! g > 5 7! * K . Z 6 ! F @. M J ! g > J1 : = : 4.- ! (* y"# \# G.i J & (* J . \a @
"%@ !g> & .6 ! 6 !1F8 J F & !* K J * : = : - ! F @. M J J i F ( *0 ! L 1 # J . J s.*$.6 (L (* OCQ D # .6 x
!E . J L* ! "#
(b, x, i, j) 41W
! Z6 J 1 .1[
j
&
i
Singleton Betting
Integer Program
Fractional Solution
Objective Function
Extra Information
z
x
(b, x, i) 41W
!E . J L* ! "#
! Z6 J ! "# $ J W [ "a = J ! . !@1 .6 .1* .
i
"# " X !LF $ # 5
\= W 1# J !L E# V G.i :V # : - !g> 5
"# Y J & 3. $ % # 41W
1# J !( # $.63 8* # !F !+ ! !@1 iF
J G. "6 . !g> # \a @ !g> 5 7"# $1 \= W
\= W ! .* $. "6 _6 5 !+ d ,-& "# 6& J1 "# +F "# 1[ $.6Fw 1# J !( < E* ! J o m T = k E 1 # L . *1 ! ! 2 & . Z 6
"# N1[ `6 9* l[ ! (6
1 # J ! L + &
L K @ . Z 6 61 * & . Z 6 . # . Z 6 $ K \ = W
"(@ 4 ' # !g> ` [ ! & J & 1# 6 1@& :a ! ! %G & & $.0 .& L "- 1 > h#1 $.6 3 8* ( 7 ` -
$.0 , -& 5# (6& ! "E>*
. Z 6 W [ A1 * ! L K @ . Z 6 ! # \ = W 1 # J ! ( ! g > & . > (* ! * 7 E# V n Va !g> J1 # : - ! .
J $ @ & .6 & jl m* $.* ! ! Z6 W1
bf# .6 *.6 ( E# V Z Va & .. J * 1 (6
& OHQ ,@ (*0 1 $.0 "#! { * [ & $.6 om (* .
L 3 8* +F ! [ ( * & & OCQ & OqQ
J !
|
!a # (L 7}+*& +a 1* (F 1Ka~ ( .F=
Cq| 7)3* #.( [2] Y. Chen, L. Fortnow, E. Nikodova, D. Pennock. “Betting on Permutations”, Proceedings of the ACM Conference on Electronic Commerce, 2007.
[3] M. Ghodsi, M. Mahini, V. Mirrokni, M. Zadimoghaddam. “Permutation Betting Markets: Singleton Betting with Extra Information”,
Proceedings of the ACM Conference on Electronic Commerce, 2009.
[4] D. Pennock, R. Sami. “Computational Aspects of Prediction Markets”, In Algorithmic Game Theory (N. Nissan, T. Roughgarden, E.
Tardos, V. Vazirani, eds.), Cambridge University Press, 2007.
[5] G. Tziralis, I. Tatsiopoulos. “Prediction Markets: An Extended Literature Review”, J. Prediction Markets, 1(1), 2006.

OCQ