Office of the Superintendent of Schools MONTGOMERY COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS Rockville, Maryland August 19, 2003 MEMORANDUM To: Members of the Board of Education From: Jerry D. Weast, Superintendent of Schools Subject: Report on Preliminary SAT (PSAT) Participation and Performance The number of tenth grade students taking the Preliminary SAT (PSAT) as a way of establishing a personal benchmark in preparation for more rigorous studies and assessing their readiness for college has increased substantially in the Montgomery County Public Schools over the past three years, rising from just 30 percent of sophomores in the fall of 1999 to 82.5 percent of last year’s class. The dramatic increase has been achieved among every race and ethnic group, as the school system continues to expand opportunities for student success. A new report by the Office of Shared Accountability (OSA) shows that in the 2002-2003 school year the PSAT was taken by 8,954 tenth grade students, the largest number ever taking the test in the school system and among the highest percentages in Maryland. The participation rate across Maryland last year is estimated at 65 percent, compared to 82.5 percent in Montgomery County. At the same time, the average verbal, math, and writing scores on the PSAT have remained relatively constant since 2001, when the number of tenth graders taking the PSAT nearly tripled in one year, from just 2,885 students (30.4 percent of the class) in the 1999-2000 school year to 8,174 students (81 percent) the following year. The most recent test was taken on Tuesday, October 15, 2002, at the height of the sniper incident that so seriously impacted our schools. The expansion of the PSAT has had an immediate influence in key areas of student participation. For example, the percentage of African American students taking the test increased from just 15.7 percent in the 2000-2001 school year to 74.4 percent last year. Among Hispanic students, the participation rate increased from 13.8 percent to 68.6 percent. In fact, the expansion of the PSAT program was systemwide, with the participation rate increasing from 44.4 percent in 2000 to 90.2 percent last year among Asian American students and from 36.8 percent to 88.6 percent among white students. Interestingly, the greatest gains in student participation were among students in non-honors and lower-level mathematics and English courses. For example, the participation rate increased significantly among students taking regular English in tenth grade, from 18 percent in October 1999 to 80 percent in October 2002. In most honors and other advanced courses, the participation rate on the PSAT doubled and now includes nearly all students in those courses. The PSAT, a national exam provided by the Educational Testing Service as a preparation for taking the SAT and a qualifying measure for certain scholarships, is an increasingly important component of the ongoing efforts by this administration to provide more opportunities for student participation in higher- Members of the Board of Education 2 August 19, 2003 level academics. High school principals, teachers, and guidance counselors are using the results of the exam to provide students with an early assessment of their readiness for more rigorous studies during the final two years of high school, including enrollment in honors and Advanced Placement courses and other preparation for college. Next week, the release of the 2003 SAT scores is expected to show continued growth in the number of twelfth grade students taking that exam, in part as a result of this initiative. I believe even higher levels of participation are possible as high schools continue to encourage more students to aspire to higher levels of academic studies. The implementation of the PSAT, as a free service of the school system, was implemented in the 2000-2001 school year as part of the comprehensive reform efforts approved by the Board of Education. The testing opportunity is intended for tenth grade students who are in the regular high school degree program, not including certain special education students in certificate programs, students in the English for Speakers of Other Languages (ESOL) program, and students who are absent on the testing date. The initiative began following reports on the relatively low student participation rate in honors and Advanced Placement courses, inadequate student preparation for the SAT, and a comparatively high rate of remediation in mathematics and English among students who seek post-graduate studies at Montgomery College. Improvements are continuing to be made in all areas, and 20 of 23 high schools were recently named among the top schools in the nation by Newsweek magazine based on an analysis of Advanced Placement testing. A comprehensive assessment of the progress made since the 1999 report of the Work Group on Honors/Advanced Placement Policies, Practices, and Enrollment is being prepared for next month. Preliminary research work by OSA also is beginning to show that PSAT data can be used by students and staff to predict potential success in three important areas of high school outcomes: (1) attaining at least a score of “3” or higher on a related Advanced Placement test; (2) attaining at least 550 on a related SAT score; and (3) the likelihood for remedial course-taking upon college entry. The score ranges on the PSAT can be used by school staff to encourage and support students in taking more challenging academic courses and preparing themselves for post-high school studies. A detailed report on the PSAT results and related analysis is attached for your review. I strongly believe that as the PSAT becomes more ingrained as a standard within our schools—and other ongoing educational reforms continue to make progress—the academic potential and achievement of our students will improve as well. The offering of the PSAT in the tenth grade serves as an “early warning” signal to students who might not otherwise take the necessary steps to prepare themselves for more rigorous studies, and it provides our schools with another important opportunity to identify students who may have untapped capabilities that might not be otherwise apparent. I am deeply encouraged by the progress made thus far, and I want to congratulate our high school principals and staff for their commitment to the higher standards this assessment represents. JDW:kmy Attachment Copy to: Executive Staff Principals A THREE-YEAR REVIEW OF PSAT PARTICIPATION AND PERFORMANCE AMONG GRADE 10 STUDENTS IN THE MONTGOMERY COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS Office of Shared Accountability August 2003 John C. Larson, Ph.D. Coordinator, Applied Research Wesley L. Boykin, Ph.D., M.P.H. Director, Shared Accountability OFFICE OF SHARED ACCOUNTABILITY Dr. Wesley L. Boykin, Director 850 Hungerford Drive Rockville, Maryland 20850 (301) 279-3448 Dr. Jerry D. Weast Superintendent of Schools Dr. Frieda K. Lacey Chief of Staff A THREE-YEAR REVIEW OF PSAT PARTICIPATION AND PERFORMANCE AMONG GRADE 10 STUDENTS IN THE MONTGOMERY COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS Executive Summary As part of Superintendent Jerry Weast’s Call to Action for raising academic standards in county high schools, the systemwide Preliminary SAT/National Merit Scholarship Qualifying Test (PSAT) testing of Grade 10 students was begun in October 2000. The purpose was to identify students with strong academic performance who, in the past, may not have taken Honors or Advanced Placement (AP) courses, and to encourage and support them in taking a rigorous course of study. The costs of the systemwide PSAT testing were paid by the school district. The PSAT administered in Grade 10 also can serve as an early signal to many students who, although not enrolled in the most advanced courses, could nevertheless improve their academic preparation during the final two years of high school. The Educational Testing Service (ETS) provides individual student results and results for each school two to three months after the October testing, and school personnel have been able to use those results for making course decisions and planning. However, because ETS does not have available the complete roster of MCPS students, their demographic features and their academic levels, the ETS reports are incomplete for the purposes of systemwide monitoring. This report provides a systemwide summary of the PSAT results for Grade 10 students for fall 2000, 2001, and 2002. The following points summarize the major findings. • The Grade 10 PSAT participation rose from 2,885 (30 percent) in the 1999-2000 school year to 8,174 (81 percent) in the 2000-2001 school year. In the 2002-2003 school year, 8,954 (82.5 percent) Grade 10 students took the PSAT. By comparison, the Grade 10 PSAT participation rate in the aggregate of other Maryland school districts for October 2002 was estimated at 65 percent, based on College Board reports and Maryland state enrollment data. • The PSAT participation rose dramatically for African American and Hispanic students from close to 15 percent in October 1999 to 74 percent for African American students and 69 percent for Hispanic students in October 2002. • The Grade 10 PSAT participation rates ranged from 69 percent to 97 percent among high schools in October 2002. Close to half of the students at the lowest levels of the Grade 10 mathematics or English curriculum took the PSAT, and over 96 percent of the Grade 10 students in the upper-level mathematics or English courses took the PSAT. • The PSAT Verbal, Mathematics and Writing scores have varied little among Grade 10 students over the past three years. The combined PSAT Total score of 136.3 for MCPS in October 2002 was about one-fourth of a standard deviation higher than the 128 average estimated for non-MCPS districts in Maryland, where a considerably lower percentage of students were tested. This means that, for example, the student with the median PSAT Total score from non-MCPS districts stands at only the 41st percentile among the PSAT scores in MCPS. Office of Shared Accountability i A THREE-YEAR REVIEW OF PSAT PARTICIPATION AND PERFORMANCE AMONG GRADE 10 STUDENTS IN THE MONTGOMERY COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS Background The Preliminary SAT/National Merit Scholarship Qualifying Test (PSAT/NMSQT or PSAT) was designed to identify the top academic talent in United States high schools. The National Merit Scholarship Corporation (NMSC), using test score information from the College Board’s PSAT administration to about 1.36 million high school students in the fall of their junior year, identified about 34,000 students (2.5%) as “commended students” for their high scores.1 Further selection procedures identified about 16,000 students (about 1%) as semifinalists in the NMSC competition. Ultimately, about 8,000 finalists are selected to receive Merit Scholarships. The PSAT was envisioned as a practice test for students to prepare for the SAT, and typically taken in the junior and/or senior year of high school.2 The PSAT test items on verbal and mathematics reasoning skills and the test directions are quite similar to those found on the SAT. Students and school staff can use PSAT scores to gauge a student’s level of preparation for the academic rigors of college. The Educational Testing Service (ETS), in collaboration with the College Board, provides students and schools with individualized reports on areas of strength and weakness that can be used to help guide decisions about course selections during subsequent semesters in high school. PSAT scores in verbal, mathematics, and writing skills are each scaled from 20 to 80. The average scores for high school juniors nationwide were around 48 in verbal, 49 in mathematics, and 46 in writing. Studies published by the College Board show the links between the PSAT scores and various Advanced Placement (AP) test scores.3 For example, about half of the high school juniors who scored in the range of 46 to 50 on the verbal section also attained a score of at least three on the AP English Language test. The PSAT also is useful among high school sophomores as a guide to academic course placements and as a stimulating challenge for students to take more rigorous courses. Grade 10 students who review their PSAT scores in the winter still have two full years of high school to enhance their college preparation. In contrast, PSAT scores may have limited effects on high school juniors’ course-taking decisions because the scores are obtained close to the end of high school programs. Partly for this reason, the use of the PSAT as a guidance tool has become more popular among high school sophomores. For example, the 910,600 sophomores who took the PSAT in fall of 2002 represented an increase of 76 percent over the 517,221 sophomores who took the test 10 years earlier.4 PSAT administration to high school sophomores in Maryland is widespread. For example, the 44,043 PSAT scores from Maryland sophomores in fall 2002 represented 69 percent of the estimated 65,000 Grade 10 students in Maryland. 1 The information in this paragraph was taken from the National Merit Scholarship Corporation Web site (www.nationalmerit.org). 2 See the College Board Web site for more detailed information and score summaries (www.collegeboard.com). 3 Camara, W.J., and Millsap, R. (1998). Using the PSAT/NMSQT and Course Grades in Predicting Success in the Advanced Placement Program. College Board Report No. 98-4,, New York, NY: The College Board. 4 The College Board. PSAT/NMSQT Summary Report, Maryland, 2002-2003 College-bound High School Sophomores. (See Web site www.collegeboard.com.) Office of Shared Accountability 1 As part of the Montgomery County Public Schools (MCPS) Call to Action for raising academic standards in high schools, the systemwide PSAT testing of Grade 10 students was initiated in fall 2000. The purpose was to identify students with strong academic performance who may not have taken Honors or AP courses in the past, and to encourage and support them in taking a rigorous course of study. The costs of the systemwide PSAT testing were paid by the school district. At the same time, the Student Outcomes and Achievement Report (SOAR), published annually by the Maryland Higher Education Commission (MHEC), had documented that significant numbers of MCPS graduates attending Montgomery College were required to take remedial courses in mathematics, reading, or English composition before they could take college creditbearing courses. Those findings are important because one-third of MCPS graduates attend Montgomery College. Results for the Class of 2000 (the most recent data available) showed, for example, that 57 percent of the MCPS graduates at Montgomery College were required to take remedial mathematics courses in their first year. The remedial placement rates for reading and English were 24 percent and 28 percent respectively.5 Therefore, the PSAT administered in Grade 10 can serve as an early signal to many students who, although not enrolled in the most advanced courses, could nevertheless improve their academic preparation during the final two years of high school before enrolling in Montgomery College. Purpose This report provides a systemwide summary of the PSAT results for Grade 10 students for fall 2000, 2001, and 2002. ETS provides individual student school results within two to three months after the October testing, allowing ample time for school personnel to use those results for course decisions and planning. However, ETS does not have the complete roster of all students enrolled in MCPS, their demographic features, and their academic levels. Therefore, it was necessary to merge individual PSAT records with existing student records in order to provide a systemwide summary of test participation and performance. Results are summarized for each school and for the following groups of students in the following groups: • Racial/ethnic groups • Special education • Gender • Level of mathematics course • Free and Reduced-price Meal • Level of English course System • English for Speakers of Other Languages (ESOL) In addition, this report provides some guidelines for interpreting the PSAT scores. The success in engaging high school sophomores in a rigorous, college preparatory test can be gauged just by reviewing the PSAT participation rates. The findings below show considerable success in that regard. However, interpreting the utility of the PSAT score for future course placement decisions is another matter. Our analyses examined the relationship between Grade 10 PSAT scores and important high school outcomes such as (1) attaining a score of three or higher on an AP examination, (2) attaining an SAT verbal or mathematics score of 550 or higher by the senior 5 Memorandum to the Board of Education, January 22, 2003. Office of Shared Accountability 2 year, and (3) likelihood for needing remedial course work in mathematics, reading, or English composition upon college entry. The results below suggest PSAT score ranges that pertain to those three high school outcomes and, thereby, provide school staff with a means to (1) identify academically promising students who may be overlooked for more challenging assignments based upon course work alone, and (2) identify students in a given course of study who may need further support to mitigate the likelihood of remedial course work upon college entry. Findings PSAT Participation Rates. The systemwide testing of Grade 10 students on the PSAT began in October 2000.6 Previously, about 30 percent of the Grade 10 students took the PSAT. In October 2000, 81 percent of the Grade 10 students took the PSAT. In the two subsequent years, 80.6 percent and 82.5 percent, respectively, of Grade 10 students took the PSAT (see Table 1). Thus, the PSAT testing program nearly tripled the proportion of Grade 10 students taking the college preparatory test. Table 1. PSAT Participation Rate Among Grade 10 Students, 1998-2003 TOTAL Native Am. Asian African Am. White Hispanic % Tested Enrolled n Tested % Tested Enrolled n Tested % Tested Enrolled n Tested % Tested Enrolled n Tested % Tested Enrolled n Tested % Tested Enrolled n Tested 1998 28.8% 8701 2510 23.5% 34 8 39.2% 1258 493 11.1% 1830 203 37.8% 4545 1717 8.6% 1034 89 1999 26.6% 9159 2433 7.7% 26 2 36.1% 1255 453 12.5% 1940 243 34.3% 4708 1616 9.7% 1230 119 YEAR 2000 2001 30.4% 81.0% 9478 10094 2885 8174 31.8% 73.3% 22 30 7 22 44.4% 88.1% 1365 1380 606 1216 15.7% 72.2% 1961 2020 307 1458 36.8% 88.0% 4865 5238 1790 4608 13.8% 61.0% 1265 1426 175 870 2002 80.6% 10464 8433 81.0% 21 17 88.2% 1514 1336 72.3% 2157 1559 87.2% 5220 4550 62.6% 1552 971 2003 82.5% 10853 8954 77.8% 36 28 90.2% 1557 1405 74.4% 2417 1798 88.6% 5133 4550 68.6% 1710 1173 The percentage of sophomores taking the PSAT prior to October 2000 was not the same for all groups of students defined by racial/ethnic group, or by level of academic courses. Therefore, the effect of the PSAT testing program was not the same for all groups. For example, the 6 Hereafter in the text and tables, the school years are denoted by the spring of the school year, even though the PSAT is administered in the fall of the school year. Office of Shared Accountability 3 percentage of Grade 10 African American students tested on the PSAT rose from about 16 percent in 1999-2000 to 74 percent in 2002-03. A similar dramatic increase was seen among Hispanic students in the sophomore class. The percentage of Asian and White students taking the PSAT increased greatly, if not so dramatically, as a result of the PSAT testing program. The attempt to test all Grade 10 students did not reach everyone. Overall, about 17 percent of the Grade 10 students in 2003 did not take the PSAT. Table 2 shows that, over the past three years, the PSAT participation rate was lower among students in the lower levels of the mathematics and English courses. However, the PSAT testing program had the greatest effect on students in those lower-level courses. For example, for students in the regular English courses, the PSAT testing program expanded the PSAT participation rate nearly fivefold, from 18 percent in 2000 to 80 percent in 2003. For students in the Algebra 1 sections in Grade 10, the PSAT testing program expanded the PSAT participation rate tenfold–from 5.8 percent in 2000 to 58 percent in 2003. At the level of academically challenging Honors courses in English or mathematics (Honors geometry or higher), the PSAT testing program roughly doubled the percentage of students taking the PSAT in 2003 compared with 2000. In those advanced courses, virtually all Grade 10 students (approximately 95%) took the PSAT in 2003. Figure 1 shows the PSAT participation rate by high school for 2000, the year just before the PSAT testing program, and 2003. In 2003, three high schools had Grade 10 PSAT participation rates above 90 percent, 14 high schools had PSAT participation rates in the range of 80 to 89 percent, and six schools had PSAT participation rates below 80 percent. Office of Shared Accountability 4 Table 2. PSAT Participation Rate By Level Of Mathematics and English Course, 1998-2003 Grd.10 Math Grd.10 English < Alg.1 % Tested Enrolled n Tested Alg.1 % Tested Enrolled n Tested Reg.Geo. % Tested Enrolled n Tested H.Geo. % Tested Enrolled n Tested Alg.2 % Tested Enrolled n Tested Alg.2 & Anl. % Tested Enrolled n Tested >= PreCalc. % Tested Enrolled n Tested ESOL / % Tested Basic Enrolled n Tested Regular % Tested Enrolled n Tested Honors % Tested Enrolled n Tested Office of Shared Accountability 1998 3.6% 1006 36 3.2% 1127 36 21.7% 3302 717 42.9% 266 114 43.2% 1034 447 60.9% 1658 1009 64.8% 233 151 1.8% 823 15 16.4% 4745 779 55.4% 2962 1640 1999 4.4% 1139 50 4.3% 1344 58 19.1% 3280 628 39.8% 279 111 43.2% 1030 445 57.5% 1721 990 56.0% 268 150 1.7% 697 12 14.2% 5144 731 51.8% 3127 1619 YEAR 2000 2001 6.5% 53.2% 1104 1251 72 665 5.8% 58.5% 1307 1319 76 771 24.0% 85.9% 3456 3418 830 2935 46.1% 94.8% 371 443 171 420 44.4% 91.8% 964 1106 428 1015 60.2% 96.8% 1840 2081 1107 2015 61.5% 96.1% 317 356 195 342 3.7% 27.8% 649 1112 24 309 17.6% 81.8% 5214 4845 918 3962 55.2% 96.9% 3407 4025 1879 3899 2002 51.7% 1202 621 58.5% 1278 748 83.0% 3264 2708 91.9% 454 417 91.5% 1278 1169 97.5% 2350 2292 97.2% 464 451 35.3% 1197 422 79.3% 4369 3463 95.7% 4738 4536 2003 55.0% 1066 586 57.5% 1313 755 83.8% 3306 2772 94.4% 449 424 92.9% 1483 1377 97.4% 2530 2464 97.5% 561 547 40.2% 1207 485 79.9% 4240 3388 96.0% 5284 5071 5 Figure 1. Grade 10 PSAT Participation Rate For High Schools, 2000 And 2003 CHURCHILL HS WOOTTON HS POOLESVILLE HS WHITMAN HS DAMASCUS HS B.C.C. HS WALTER JOHNSON HS SHERWOOD HS J. HUBERT BLAKE HS SPRINGBROOK HS R. MONTGOMERY HS PAINT BRANCH HS NORTHWEST HS MAGRUDER HS M. BLAIR HS ROCKVILLE HS EINSTEIN HS SENECA VALLEY HS YEAR QUINCE ORCHARD HS KENNEDY HS WHEATON HS 2000 WATKINS MILL HS GAITHERSBURG HS 2003 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 Percentage of Grade 10 with PSAT PSAT Performance. Grade 10 PSAT scores for MCPS have been quite stable over the past three years. Table 3 on page 7 shows that the average Verbal score increased slightly from 44.0 in 2001 to 44.4 in 2003. The average Mathematics score in 2003, 46.3, was an increase of .2 point over the 2001 average score. The average Writing score of 45.6 was the same as in 2001. These fluctuations in scores over the past three years amount to less than 5 percent of one standard deviation. These scores, representing about 83 percent of the MCPS sophomores in 2003, are significantly higher than the PSAT scores for sophomores in the other school districts in Maryland. Using data summaries published by the College Board for the 2003 sophomores in Maryland, the estimated scores for non-MCPS sophomores were 41.8 in Verbal, 42.5 in Mathematics, and 43.7 Office of Shared Accountability 6 in Writing.7 The PSAT Verbal, Mathematics, and Writing scores have varied little among Grade 10 students over the past three years. The combined PSAT Total Score of 136.3 for MCPS in October 2002 was about one-fourth of a standard deviation higher than the 128 average estimated for non-MCPS districts in Maryland where a considerably lower percentage of students were tested. This means that, for example, the student with the median PSAT Total score from non-MCPS districts stands at only the 41st percentile among the PSAT scores in MCPS. Based on the reported scores and the Grade 10 enrollment estimated for the state of Maryland, the PSAT participation rate for non-MCPS sophomores was estimated at 64.8 percent compared with 83 percent for MCPS sophomores. Table 3. Grade 10 PSAT Average Scores in MCPS, 1998-2003 YEAR 1998 Verbal Mean s.d. n Math Mean s.d. n Writing 1999 2000 50.8 10.1 2510 52.1 10.2 2510 49.7 10.9 2433 51.3 10.4 2433 50.4 11.1 2885 52.1 10.8 2885 * * * Mean s.d. n 2001 44.0 12.4 8174 46.1 12.4 8174 45.6 10.1 8174 2002 44.4 11.7 8433 45.8 12.0 8433 46.0 10.8 8433 2003 44.4 12.2 8954 46.3 12.5 8954 45.6 10.0 8954 * Data not compiled. Note: PSAT scores range from 20 to 80. With the large increase in the percentage of sophomores tested in 2001, the PSAT average scores dropped significantly from their respective levels in the years prior to 2001, when only 26 to 30 percent of the sophomores were tested. This decrease in the systemwide average scores was due to the inclusion of many students with lower academic performance levels. The inclusion of such students in taking a college preparatory placement test was, of course, the main rationale for the systemwide PSAT testing program. PSAT scores for student demographic groups are summarized in Table A1 in the technical appendix. Those data show that Grade 10 PSAT scores for Asian and White groups average about one standard deviation unit higher than the average scores for African American and Hispanic students. Racial/ethnic group differences are shown below in Figure 2. Because racial/ethnic group differences were largely similar across the verbal, mathematics, and writing tests, Figure 2 on page 8 shows the sum of those scores, also known as the PSAT Selection Index. The Selection Index is used by the National Merit Scholarship Corporation for identifying semifinalists for the National Merit Scholarship competition. 7 The College Board. PSAT/NMSQT Summary Report, Maryland, 2002– 2003 College-bound High School Sophomores. (See Web site www.collegeboard.com.) Office of Shared Accountability 7 The boxplots in Figure 2 show the median scores for each group as the small white line in the middle of each “box.” The upper and lower edges of the boxes show the 75th and 25th percentile scores for each group, and the ends of the “whiskers” show the extreme scores for each group. These results suggest that the African American and Hispanics scoring at the 75th percentile in their respective groups stand close to the Asian or White students scoring at the 25th percentile in their respective groups. Figure 2. Racial/Ethnic Group Differences in the PSAT Selection Index, 2001-2003 (sum of Verbal, Mathematics, and Writing scores) 240 220 200 180 160 PSAT Selection Index 140 120 100 2001 80 2002 60 2003 Asian African Am. White Hispanic Note: Information compiled for each year is the sum of verbal, mathematics, and writing scores. Much of the racial/ethnic group differences on the PSAT probably are due to the group differences in levels of academic course placement. Table A2 in the technical appendix shows the PSAT performance levels for those Grade 10 students who are enrolled in different levels of mathematics and English courses. These academic group differences are shown in Figures 3 and 4. Close to 10 PSAT Mathematics points separate the median scores of students in the Algebra 1 group from those in the regular geometry group, and another 10 points separate the median of the Algebra 2 group from the regular geometry group median. Considering the results noted above for the state of Maryland, these results suggest that the median PSAT Mathematics score for Office of Shared Accountability 8 Honors geometry group in MCPS is close to the mean score for the top two-thirds of Grade 10 students in Maryland. Office of Shared Accountability 9 Figure 3. Grade 10 PSAT Mathematics Score Differences for Students in Different Mathematics Classes, 2001-2003 80 70 60 Grade 10 PSAT Math 50 40 2001 30 2002 20 2003 < Alg.1 Reg.Geo. Alg.1 Alg.2 Honors Geo. >= PreCalc. Alg.2/ Anlysis Figure 4. Grade 10 PSAT Verbal Score Differences for Students in Different English Classes, 2001-2003 80 70 60 Grade 10 PSAT Verbal 50 40 2001 30 2002 2003 20 Basic Office of Shared Accountability Regular Honors 10 The median performance of students in the Honors English sections was about 13 PSAT Verbal points above the median of the regular English sections, and that median was, in turn, about eight points higher than the median for the students in the ESOL or basic English courses. The average PSAT Verbal score for the top two-thirds of the sophomores in Maryland, 42, lay in between the median scores of the MCPS regular and Honors English sections. As with the PSAT Mathematics scores, the PSAT Verbal scores for students in the various academic course levels have fluctuated little over the past three years. A more detailed analysis examined the racial/ethnic group differences among students who shared the same type of mathematics and English course levels and the same status of Free and Reduced-price Meals System (FARMS). Racial/ethnic group differences in FARMS status and in percentages of students enrolled in those various course levels accounted for some but not all of the racial/ethnic group differences in PSAT scores. For example, the PSAT Verbal score averages for African American and Hispanic students differed by .93 to 1.0 s.d. units from the average for White students, but among students that shared the same levels of mathematics and English courses, those differences were, respectively, .31 and .25 s.d. units. Also, the average PSAT Mathematics score for African American or Hispanic students was .97 s.d. units lower than that for White students, but among students that shared the same levels of mathematics and English courses, those differences were, respectively, .33 and .25 s.d. units. Therefore, factors other than course placement and FARMS contribute to racial/ethnic group differences in PSAT scores. PSAT Performance Differences Among High Schools. Figure 5 shows the PSAT total scale for schools, termed the Selection Index, which is used by the National Merit Scholarship Corporation in selecting national merit semifinalists. Since the scores changed relatively little across years, Figure 5 shows the three-year averages of the PSAT scores. (See appendix Table A3 for more detailed summaries of the three sub-scores across the three years.) Variations among high schools in Grade 10 PSAT scores are similar to the variations observed for Grade 12 SAT scores. As might be expected, schools with relatively more high-scoring students upon entry to high school, and consequently with higher percentages of students in the upper-level courses, also tend to have higher PSAT averages in Grade 10 than do schools with relatively more students in the lower-level courses. Therefore, the schools’ average PSAT scores from the October administration in Grade 10 represent largely the students’ incoming academic levels mixed with about one year’s effect of the high schools’ academic programs. In order to gain a clearer picture of the relative strength of the high schools’ academic programs, Figure 5 also shows the PSAT total scores for schools as if the schools all had the same proportions of students at each level of the mathematics curriculum. These “statistically adjusted” averages were obtained not by averaging the students’ scores directly, but by averaging each school’s PSAT scores for the Algebra 1 students, the Geometry students, the Algebra 2 students, etc., and then taking the average of those mean scores. This picture of the schools’ performance levels is important when judging the consistency of the academic programs among schools. For example, Figure 5 shows that 18 of the 23 high schools have average adjusted scores within only about 6 points of 140 (the district average). If matched on a course-by-course basis, these schools produce similar levels of performance on the PSAT. On the other hand, the unadjusted, observed PSAT averages among these same schools range between 122 (Einstein Office of Shared Accountability 11 HS) and 150 (R. Montgomery HS), a range of about 28 PSAT total score points. Much of the variation in the observed averages is thus due to school differences in the proportions of students at different academic levels rather than to school differences in the “output” within any given level of the academic program. Figure 5. PSAT Total Scale Averages Among High Schools, and Adjusted Averages WHITMAN HS WOOTTON HS R. MONTGOMERY HS CHURCHILL HS B.C.C. HS WALTER JOHNSON HS POOLESVILLE HS QUINCE ORCHARD HS M. BLAIR HS MAGRUDER HS SHERWOOD HS DAMASCUS HS J. HUBERT BLAKE HS ROCKVILLE HS WATKINS MILL HS GAITHERSBURG HS PAINT BRANCH HS NORTHWEST HS SPRINGBROOK HS SENECA VALLEY HS PSAT Total EINSTEIN HS Avg. of Math Group KENNEDY HS WHEATON HS 100 Means 110 120 130 140 150 160 170 PSAT Total Scale Note: Averages are adjusted as if all schools had the same proportion of students at each level of the Mathematics Curriculum. Effects of PSAT Testing Program on Subsequent Honors Course Participation. The rationale for the systemwide PSAT testing program was to identify likely candidates for increased Honors course-taking among Grade 10 students who otherwise might not have considered more challenging academic courses. One way of examining the effect of this intent is to observe the Office of Shared Accountability 12 incidence of Honors course-taking among students in the first semester of their junior year, after having taken the PSAT in Grade 10. It was possible, for the sophomores of 2001 and 2002, to record the Grade 11 Honors course enrollments of students one year after their PSAT testing, and to compare the potential changes in Honors course-taking found among juniors from earlier years. Figures 6 shows the percentages of Grade 11 students, from 1998 to 2003, that had PSAT scores from Grade 10. The effect of the systemwide PSAT testing program is clearly seen for the Grade 11 classes of 2002 and 2003 compared with earlier years. Figure 7 on page 13 shows the percentages of Grade 11 students in those same years who were enrolled in at least one Honors course during the first semester. The Grade 11 groups for 2001, 2002, and 2003 show gradually increasing participation in Honors classes for each of the four racial/ethnic groups. These gradual increases suggest an expanding outreach to students for Honors course-taking. However, the increases in Grade 11 Honors course-taking appeared even among the 2001 group of Grade 11 students who had not, at that time, experienced the systemwide PSAT testing in Grade 10. Therefore, the systemwide PSAT testing program for Grade 10 contributed to other activities established earlier in the schools to encourage Honors course-taking. Figure 6. Changes in Grade 10 PSAT Participation Among Students in Grade 11, 1998-2002 One year prior to systemwide Grade 10 PSAT testing Asian Am. Grade 11 Year African Am 1998 1999 White 2000 2001 Hispanic 2002 2003 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 % Grd. 11 with Grd. 10 PSAT Score Office of Shared Accountability 13 Figure 7. Changes in Honors Course Participation Among Students in Grade 11, 1998-2002 One year prior to systemwide Grade 10 PSAT testing Asian Am. Grade 11 Year African Am 1998 1999 White 2000 2001 Hispanic 2002 2003 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 % Any Honors Course, Grd.11, Sem.1 Guidelines for Using PSAT Scores to Estimate High School Outcomes. The systemwide Grade 10 PSAT testing program was intended not only to provide students with the experience of a rigorous college preparatory test, but also to provide students and school staff with information that could contribute to more advanced course placements for some students who, without more encouragement, might forgo challenging course work. The Grade 10 PSAT scores can contribute to such student guidance to the extent that the scores correlate with important high school outcomes. Moreover, it is important to establish the alignment of the PSAT scales with various academic high school outcomes so that guidance decisions can be made based on various ranges of students’ PSAT scores. For example, what is the likelihood of a student attaining an SAT Mathematics score of 550 or greater by the senior year, given various ranges of PSAT scores from Grade 10? Or, what is the likelihood of taking an Advanced Placement examination in mathematics and scoring three or higher, given any Grade 10 PSAT Mathematics score? Alternatively, for any given PSAT Verbal score in Grade 10, what is the likelihood of needing remedial reading or English composition courses in college three years later? In order to answer such questions, the following analyses linked Grade 10 PSAT scores with high school AP examination scores and SAT scores up to two years later, and with remedial course placement experiences in college three years later. The results suggest ranges of PSAT scores that may be used to guide students’ planning for their last two years in high school. Office of Shared Accountability 14 Figure 8 shows the relationship between PSAT Verbal scores from Grade 10 and three high school outcomes: (1) the likelihood of placement into a remedial reading or English composition course upon college entry three years later, (2) the likelihood of taking an AP examination in English literature or language and attaining a score of three or higher on either test, and (3) the likelihood of attaining an SAT Verbal score of 550 or higher by the senior year. (The SAT Verbal score of 550 or higher is reported by Montgomery College officials as a good indicator of college-level functioning.) In Figure 8, each PSAT Verbal score value is associated with these likelihoods based on analyses from earlier cohorts of students in MCPS. The results show, for example, that Grade 10 students with higher PSAT Verbal scores have an understandably lower likelihood for needing remedial course work than do students with lower PSAT scores. Conversely, Grade 10 students with higher PSAT Verbal scores have higher likelihoods for AP English scores of three or higher or SAT Verbal scores of 550 or higher than do their classmates with lower PSAT scores. The PSAT score associated with the “50 percent likelihood” line (on the vertical axis) suggests the PSAT score above which a favorable outcome is more likely than not. For example, attaining an AP English score of at least three becomes more likely than not for students whose PSAT Verbal scores are 42 or higher. Or, attaining an SAT Verbal score of at least 550 becomes more likely than not for students whose PSAT Verbal scores are 47 or higher. Conversely, students whose Grade 10 PSAT Verbal scores are lower than 37 are more likely than not to require a remedial reading or English course upon college entry. Figure 8. Likelihood for Three High School Outcomes, Given Grade 10 PSAT Verbal Scores 1.0 47 .9 42 .8 37 Likelihood for Verbal Outcome .7 .6 .5 .4 Verbal Outcome .3 .2 Remedial Eng/Rd .1 AP Eng. 3+ SAT >= 550 0.0 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 Grade 10 PSAT Verbal Scale Office of Shared Accountability 15 Figure 9. Distribution of Grade 10 PSAT Verbal Score Ranges Among Students in Different Levels of English Courses 100 90 9 28 82 13 80 78 70 25 60 Percentage of Group 50 46 40 PSAT Range 30 Verbal 43 - 80 20 12 10 6 0 Below Eng.10 Reg. Eng.10 Verbal 37 - 42 Verbal 20 - 36 Honors Eng.10 Grade 10 English Level These cut-scores on the PSAT Verbal scale for Grade 10 students provide some guidance for student course placement decisions, but the cut-scores should not be interpreted as rigid markers for later success or failure. For example, recall from Figure 4 that, although the median PSAT Verbal score among students in the Honors English classes is 51, some of those students have PSAT Verbal scores below 40. At the same time, many students in the regular English sections have scores well above 43 and should be considered for more advanced course placements. Figure 9 shows the percentages of students in the PSAT Verbal score ranges derived from Figure 8. These data suggest that more than one-fourth (28%) of the students in regular English sections have PSAT Verbal scores in the upper range. Also, about one-tenth of the students in the ESOL/basic English sections have PSAT Verbal scores in the upper range. Such students may benefit from encouragement and support to enroll in more challenging academic courses. A similar analysis was conducted to examine the alignment of Grade 10 PSAT Mathematics scores with subsequent SAT Mathematics scores of 550 or higher, with AP mathematics scores of three or higher (any AP calculus or statistics test) or with remedial mathematics course-taking upon college entry. The results in Figure 10 suggest that students with Grade 10 PSAT scores of 45 or higher are more likely than not to attain a score of 3 or higher on an AP mathematics test or to attain a score of at least 550 on the SAT Mathematics scale. Conversely, students with Grade 10 PSAT Mathematics scores of less than 42 are more likely than not to require remedial Office of Shared Accountability 16 mathematics coursework upon college entry. This finding suggests that the Montgomery College requirements for enrollment into college credit-bearing mathematics courses are rigorous. Note in Table A2 in the technical appendix that a score of 45 is the average PSAT Mathematics score in the Honors geometry sections of Grade 10. As with the PSAT Verbal scores, these score ranges should be interpreted as general guidelines rather than rigid cut-scores. In the context of encouraging students to take more challenging courses, the Grade 10 PSAT scores should be used to seek out promising students who would otherwise pass unnoticed for Honors course consideration. Conversely, students with PSAT scores in the lower range who are nevertheless taking challenging courses may be identified for further support and encouragement. Figure 11 shows the percentages of students scoring in the PSAT Mathematics ranges identified in Figure 10. (Only three levels of mathematics courses are shown because very few Grade 10 students in courses beyond Algebra 2 are not in the top range.) The results in Figure 11 suggest that about one in four students in the regular Geometry sections (27%) is in the upper PSAT Mathematics range, and that about one in eight Algebra 2 students (13%) is in the lower PSAT Mathematics range. The information in Figures 8 and 10 can serve as reference guides for estimating the difficulty or ease that students may experience in attaining the three high school outcomes discussed here. In Figure 10, for example, even though remedial mathematics course placement becomes more likely than not below a score of about 42, there are nevertheless some students with scores close to 50, about 20 percent of them, who may need remedial mathematics course work. Conversely, some students with scores as low as 35 may, with effort and support, not require remedial mathematics courses upon college entry. The student’s ultimate success is determined not by test scores, but by the combination of motivation, sustained academic effort, curricular challenge, and support from school staff and parents. Office of Shared Accountability 17 Figure 10. Likelihood for Three High School Outcomes, Given Grade 10 PSAT Mathematics Scores 1.0 .9 45 .8 42 Likelihood for Math Outcome .7 .6 .5 .4 .3 Math Outcome .2 Remedial Math .1 AP Math 3+ 0.0 SAT >= 550 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 Grade 10 PSAT Math Figure 11. Distribution of Grade 10 PSAT Mathematics Score Ranges Among Students in Different Levels of Mathematics Courses 100 90 5 27 74 5 90 80 70 17 60 56 Peercentage of Group 50 40 PSAT Range 30 14 20 10 13 0 Math 46 - 80 Math 42 - 45 Math 20 - 41 <= Alg.1 Reg.Geo. Alg.2 Grade 10 Math Level Office of Shared Accountability 18 A THREE-YEAR REVIEW OF PSAT PARTICIPATION AND PERFORMANCE AMONG GRADE 10 STUDENTS IN THE MONTGOMERY COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS TECHNICAL APPENDIX Office of Shared Accountability 19 Table A1. PSAT Participation Rate and Performance for Student Demographic Groups Asian African Am. White Hispanic Female Male Current FARMS Current ESOL Current IEP % Tested n Tested PSAT Verbal PSAT Math PSAT Writing % Tested n Tested PSAT Verbal PSAT Math PSAT Writing % Tested n Tested PSAT Verbal PSAT Math PSAT Writing % Tested n Tested PSAT Verbal PSAT Math PSAT Writing % Tested n Tested PSAT Verbal PSAT Math PSAT Writing % Tested n Tested PSAT Verbal PSAT Math PSAT Writing % Tested n Tested PSAT Verbal PSAT Math PSAT Writing % Tested n Tested PSAT Verbal PSAT Math PSAT Writing % Tested n Tested PSAT Verbal PSAT Math PSAT Writing 1998 39.2% 493 48.8 54.3 . 11.1% 203 44.5 44.2 . 37.8% 1717 52.3 52.7 . 8.6% 89 46.9 46.5 . 32.8% 1434 51.1 50.8 . 24.8% 1076 50.5 53.9 . 10.8% 306 43.7 46.4 . 2.3% 9 38.9 46.9 . 11.1% 121 46.1 46.6 . 1999 36.1% 453 48.0 53.7 . 12.5% 243 41.8 41.8 . 34.3% 1616 51.7 52.4 . 9.7% 119 44.9 46.7 . 28.8% 1285 49.9 49.9 . 24.5% 1148 49.5 52.8 . 10.9% 337 41.9 45.8 . 2.7% 15 32.6 42.9 . 10.9% 131 42.2 43.4 . YEAR 2000 2001 44.4% 88.1% 606 1216 50.0 44.7 54.4 50.0 . 45.6 15.7% 72.2% 307 1458 41.2 36.2 42.2 37.5 . 40.2 36.8% 88.0% 1790 4608 52.9 47.8 53.8 49.4 . 48.4 13.8% 61.0% 175 870 42.2 36.1 43.6 37.7 . 39.8 33.9% 84.0% 1523 4108 50.3 44.5 50.5 45.3 . 46.6 27.3% 78.1% 1362 4066 50.4 43.5 53.8 46.9 . 44.5 14.4% 66.4% 462 2284 41.6 35.8 45.1 38.5 . 39.5 4.6% 33.2% 29 206 32.3 28.9 44.1 35.7 . 35.2 10.9% 57.8% 131 692 42.8 33.2 43.9 35.3 . 37.4 2002 88.2% 1336 45.3 50.8 46.5 72.3% 1559 37.3 37.4 39.9 87.2% 4550 48.2 49.0 49.5 62.6% 971 36.5 37.4 39.0 82.3% 4226 44.9 45.1 47.2 78.9% 4207 43.8 46.4 44.8 66.0% 2349 36.6 38.3 39.4 45.1% 324 30.7 38.2 36.0 59.4% 706 34.7 35.7 37.9 2003 90.2% 1405 46.4 52.2 47.0 74.4% 1798 37.3 37.9 40.3 88.6% 4550 48.7 50.1 48.9 68.6% 1173 35.9 37.5 39.7 84.5% 4442 44.6 45.5 46.6 80.6% 4512 44.2 47.1 44.7 70.4% 2721 36.2 38.5 39.7 49.7% 360 29.5 35.2 35.3 62.1% 757 33.3 35.3 37.5 Note: YEAR refers to spring of school year. No PSAT Writing data compiled prior to 2001 Office of Shared Accountability 20 Table A2. PSAT Participation Rate and Performance for Student Academic Groups Grd.10 Math < Alg.1 Alg.1 Reg.Geo. H.Geo. Alg.2 Alg.2 & Anl. >= PreCalc. Grd.10 English Basic Regular Honors % Tested n Tested PSAT Verbal PSAT Math PSAT Writing % Tested n Tested PSAT Verbal PSAT Math PSAT Writing % Tested n Tested PSAT Verbal PSAT Math PSAT Writing % Tested n Tested PSAT Verbal PSAT Math PSAT Writing % Tested n Tested PSAT Verbal PSAT Math PSAT Writing % Tested n Tested PSAT Verbal PSAT Math PSAT Writing % Tested n Tested PSAT Verbal PSAT Math PSAT Writing % Tested n Tested PSAT Verbal PSAT Math PSAT Writing % Tested n Tested PSAT Verbal PSAT Math PSAT Writing % Tested n Tested PSAT Verbal PSAT Math PSAT Writing 1998 3.6% 36 40.1 36.9 . 3.2% 36 39.5 36.7 . 21.7% 717 45.4 43.8 . 42.9% 114 49.2 48.7 . 43.2% 447 49.1 50.6 . 60.9% 1009 55.0 57.8 . 64.8% 151 60.2 68.3 . 1.8% 15 35.4 44.1 . 16.4% 779 43.6 46.1 . 55.4% 1640 53.7 54.5 . 1999 4.4% 50 35.3 34.5 . 4.3% 58 34.7 33.0 . 19.1% 628 43.5 42.8 . 39.8% 111 46.4 46.7 . 43.2% 445 48.8 49.9 . 57.5% 990 54.3 57.4 . 56.0% 150 60.6 66.3 . 1.7% 12 31.7 40.4 . 14.2% 731 41.4 44.3 . 51.8% 1619 52.9 54.1 . YEAR 2000 2001 6.5% 53.2% 72 665 34.8 32.6 36.5 33.5 . 37.3 5.8% 58.5% 76 771 34.5 31.1 33.6 31.8 . 36.6 24.0% 85.9% 830 2935 43.9 40.1 43.2 40.3 . 42.3 46.1% 94.8% 171 420 49.2 46.4 48.9 47.3 . 46.8 44.4% 91.8% 428 1015 49.9 47.0 52.4 50.5 . 47.4 60.2% 96.8% 1107 2015 55.6 53.6 58.8 58.2 . 52.9 61.5% 96.1% 195 342 62.1 60.9 66.7 66.6 . 59.8 3.7% 27.8% 24 309 31.1 30.7 42.4 35.1 . 35.8 17.6% 81.8% 918 3962 42.7 37.4 45.0 39.9 . 40.3 55.2% 96.9% 1879 3899 53.8 51.8 55.3 53.3 . 51.7 2002 51.7% 621 32.9 33.1 36.9 58.5% 748 32.4 32.6 36.2 83.0% 2708 39.9 39.5 41.5 91.9% 417 45.7 45.7 46.4 91.5% 1169 46.5 48.1 47.3 97.5% 2292 52.7 56.1 53.8 97.2% 451 58.2 64.8 59.6 35.3% 422 31.5 36.3 36.3 79.3% 3463 37.4 39.1 39.6 95.7% 4536 50.9 51.8 51.8 2003 55.0% 586 32.0 33.0 36.7 57.5% 755 30.9 30.7 36.2 83.8% 2772 39.3 39.7 41.4 94.4% 424 43.6 45.5 45.1 92.9% 1377 46.4 48.5 46.3 97.4% 2464 52.8 56.4 52.3 97.5% 547 59.7 66.0 59.1 40.2% 485 30.5 35.0 36.0 79.9% 3388 36.7 38.9 39.6 96.0% 5071 50.8 52.4 50.6 Note: YEAR refers to spring of school year. No PSAT Writing data compiled prior to 2001 Office of Shared Accountability 21 Table A3. PSAT Participation Rate and Performance for High Schools, 2001–2003 B.C.C. HS 2001 2002 2003 M. BLAIR HS 2001 2002 2003 J. HUBERT BLAKE 2001 HS 2002 2003 CHURCHILL HS 2001 2002 2003 DAMASCUS HS 2001 2002 2003 EINSTEIN HS 2001 2002 2003 GAITHERSBURG HS 2001 2002 2003 WALTER JOHNSON HS 2001 2002 2003 KENNEDY HS 2001 2002 2003 MAGRUDER HS 2001 2002 2003 R. MONTGOMERY 2001 HS 2002 2003 NORTHWEST HS 2001 2002 2003 % Tested PSAT Verbal PSAT Math PSAT Writing PSAT Total 85.4% 89.8% 89.2% 74.9% 84.0% 81.2% 85.4% 85.7% 86.7% 95.5% 95.4% 96.7% 86.2% 82.8% 89.3% 80.1% 79.6% 80.6% 66.0% 62.1% 69.4% 85.9% 87.9% 87.3% 76.4% 74.7% 76.6% 85.3% 75.8% 82.6% 85.8% 84.6% 83.8% 75.8% 83.3% 82.8% 48.8 48.2 50.3 45.1 45.2 43.6 43.9 44.5 43.8 48.9 47.9 49.8 42.5 44.0 44.1 39.2 39.2 39.2 42.4 41.8 41.4 48.2 47.7 48.8 38.2 37.4 37.7 43.6 45.0 43.9 49.7 49.7 49.5 40.1 40.7 41.9 49.4 48.0 50.8 46.6 46.2 45.5 42.8 44.3 45.2 51.7 51.5 52.4 44.9 45.6 46.4 41.1 39.7 40.2 44.4 43.3 43.1 49.2 48.8 50.5 40.4 38.6 39.8 45.8 46.3 46.2 50.0 50.0 50.9 42.6 42.8 43.6 49.2 49.1 50.5 47.2 47.1 45.8 44.7 46.1 45.6 49.5 49.5 48.8 43.8 45.6 45.3 41.6 41.5 41.8 43.4 43.3 42.4 49.1 49.3 49.0 41.3 39.9 40.7 44.8 46.1 45.3 49.8 50.6 50.2 42.3 43.5 44.3 147.4 145.2 151.5 138.9 138.5 134.9 131.4 134.8 134.7 150.1 148.9 151.0 131.2 135.2 135.8 121.9 120.4 121.2 130.3 128.4 126.9 146.5 145.9 148.3 119.9 116.0 118.2 134.1 137.4 135.4 149.5 150.4 150.6 125.0 126.9 129.8 Note: YEAR refers to spring of school year. Office of Shared Accountability 22 Table A3 (cont.). PSAT Participation Rate and Performance for High Schools, 2001–2003 PAINT BRANCH HS 2001 2002 2003 POOLESVILLE HS 2001 2002 2003 QUINCE ORCHARD HS 2001 2002 2003 ROCKVILLE HS 2001 2002 2003 SENECA VALLEY HS 2001 2002 2003 SHERWOOD HS 2001 2002 2003 SPRINGBROOK HS 2001 2002 2003 WATKINS MILL HS 2001 2002 2003 WHEATON HS 2001 2002 2003 WHITMAN HS 2001 2002 2003 WOOTTON HS 2001 2002 2003 % Tested PSAT Verbal PSAT Math PSAT Writing PSAT Total 80.6% 82.1% 83.3% 86.9% 94.3% 90.7% 85.2% 79.5% 78.5% 76.4% 80.3% 80.8% 81.5% 75.6% 79.5% 86.2% 80.4% 86.7% 86.5% 83.6% 84.1% 77.2% 70.0% 74.1% 74.1% 76.8% 75.8% 91.4% 87.7% 89.4% 92.1% 92.1% 95.3% 41.1 40.9 41.7 44.6 46.6 46.5 43.6 44.9 45.5 42.2 42.5 43.4 39.3 41.2 40.0 44.6 44.2 43.2 39.5 41.6 39.1 42.5 43.3 41.6 35.7 35.9 35.4 53.0 51.5 53.2 48.4 49.3 50.1 44.0 44.0 44.8 46.4 47.4 48.0 47.7 47.6 47.9 44.1 44.3 45.4 42.4 42.8 42.5 46.9 45.5 45.3 42.4 42.5 41.2 44.6 44.2 43.4 37.7 37.1 37.4 54.0 52.2 54.7 53.0 52.4 53.3 43.1 42.2 43.2 45.8 47.6 46.1 44.8 46.5 47.2 43.6 44.4 44.0 42.9 42.4 41.4 45.6 45.6 44.8 43.9 44.1 42.0 43.9 45.0 43.0 39.5 38.2 38.6 52.6 52.1 53.0 49.1 51.1 50.3 128.2 127.1 129.7 136.8 141.6 140.6 136.2 139.0 140.7 129.9 131.2 132.8 124.6 126.3 123.9 137.1 135.3 133.3 125.8 128.2 122.3 131.0 132.4 128.0 112.9 111.2 111.4 159.6 155.8 160.9 150.6 152.7 153.6 Note: YEAR refers to spring of school year. Office of Shared Accountability 23
© Copyright 2025 Paperzz