The Effect of Mercury vs LED Light Sources on Tack

TheEffectofMercuryvsLEDLight
SourcesonTackFreeCuring
UVLED2015
MikeIdacavage,NeilCramer,Ma;hewSchreiber,andAmeliaDavenport
ColoradoPhotopolymerSoluHons
October28,2015
OxygenInhibi?on
Unpolymerized“tacky” Layer
FactorsAffecHngOxygenDiffusion
O2 O2O2 O2O O O2O O2 O
O2 O2 O2 2 2 O2 2 O2 2
Viscosity
PolymerizedLayer
GelPoint
Substrate
CrosslinkingDensity/Tg
OxygenSolubility
2
OxygenInhibi?on
I
• IniHaHon
I•+M
I•+O2
IM•+O2•
IM•+M
• PropagaHon
IMM•+M
IMMM•+M
UVEnergy
2I•
IM•
I+O2•
M-O-O•
IMM•
IMMM•
IMMMM•
I=IniHatorM=Monomer(oranyacrylate)P=Polymerchain
3
OvercomingOxygenInhibi?on
TotalRateofOxygen
ConsumpHonwithinthe
Sample
FluxofOxygenintothe
Sample
-  OxygenSolubility
-  Viscosity
IfFO2>RI--OxygeninhibiHonwill
notbeovercome
IfFO2<RI--OxygeninhibiHon
willbeovercome,resulHngintack
freesurfaces,providedexposure
Hmesarelongenough
AsformulaHonpolymerizes,
viscosityincreasesandthe
fluxofoxygenintothe
sampledecreases
4
OvercomingOxygenInhibi?on
ParametersAffecHngOxygenInhibiHon
IrradiaHonIntensity
PhotoiniHatorConcentraHon
PhotoiniHator/IrradiaHonSourceEfficiency/Overlap
AffectsRI
Viscosity
FuncHonality/Crosslinking
AffectsFO2
ExposureTime
OvercomesoxygeninhibiHonifRI>FO2
5
CuringSetup
300W/inchHeraeusF300HBulb
25WHeraeus385nmLED
XXXfpm
BeltSpeed/ExposureLength=ExposureTime(Dose)
6
Irgacure 184 Absorption Spectrum
7
TPOAbsorp?onSpectrum
8
UVlampoutput
9
MatchingPIandUVBulb
10
SurfaceCureUsingUV-LED
11
SurfaceCureUsingUV-LED
12
OxygenInhibi?onMercuryBulb
PhotoiniHatoris1-hydroxy-cyclohexyl-phenyl-ketone(184)orTPO
FormulaHonswerespreadontoglasssubstrateswitha128umdrawdownbar
SamplesareirradiatedonaconveyorsystemwithanF300HeraeusHBulb
13
OxygenInhibi?onMercuryBulb
PhotoiniHatoris1-hydroxy-cyclohexyl-phenyl-ketone(184)orTPO
FormulaHonswerespreadontoglasssubstrateswitha128umdrawdownbar
SamplesareirradiatedonaconveyorsystemwithanF300HeraeusHBulb
14
OxygenInhibi?onMercuryBulb
PhotoiniHatoris1-hydroxy-cyclohexyl-phenyl-ketone(184)orTPO
FormulaHonswerespreadontoglasssubstrateswitha128umdrawdownbar
SamplesareirradiatedonaconveyorsystemwithanF300HeraeusHBulb
15
OxygenInhibi?on–Viscosity&Thiols
16
DiluentEffectonMaterialProper?es
17
OxygenInhibi?on–UVvsUV-Vis
PhotoiniHatoris1-hydroxy-cyclohexyl-phenyl-ketone(184)orTPO
FormulaHonswerespreadontoglasssubstrateswitha128umdrawdownbar
SamplesareirradiatedonaconveyorsystemwithanF300HeraeusHBulb
18
UVvsUV-VisIni?ator–Viscosity&Thiols
19
Tradi?onalvsThiol-BasedFormula?ons
20
MercuryvsLED-Acrylates
HBulb–300W/inch385nmLED–25W
~2inchheight6mm(.24inch)height
21
MercuryvsLED-Acrylates
22
MercuryvsLED-Thiols
23
Summary–O2Inhibi?on
!  ScaleswithphotoiniHatorconcentraHoninallcases(UV,
UV-Vis,andLED).
!  Scalesnon-linearlywithphotoiniHatorconcentraHon
!  Isaffectedbyviscosity
!  IsaffectedbytheaddiHonofthiolmonomer
!  WasrelaHvelyunaffectedbydifferenttypesofacrylates
!  Mercury:UVvsUV-Vis
!  Veryli;leeffect
24
Summary–MercuryvsLED
!  Achievingtack-freecuringwithLEDismoredifficult
!  Mercuryappearstobebe;erthanLEDfortackfreecuring
!  Thismaybeduetothebroaderwavelength(most
likelythelowwavelengths)
!  TheLEDlightwasmuchlowerpower,sothismayalso
playasignificantrole
!  Thiol-basedsystemsandhigherphotoiniHator
concentraHonscanresultincomparaHvebeltspeedsto
classicMercuryLampcuring
25
Acknowledgments
MiwonSpecialtyChemicalCo.,Ltd
CPSTechnicalTeam
26
ThankYou
ContactinformaHon:
Dr.MikeJ.Idacavage
VPBusinessDevelopment
ColoradoPhotopolymerSoluHons
1880S.FlaHronCt
Boulder,CO80301
303-551-3213
mike.idacavage@cpspolymers.com
www.cpspolymers.com
27