Environ. Sci. Technol. 2001, 35, 863-873 Processes Influencing Rainfall Deposition of Mercury in Florida JANE L. GUENTZEL* Departments of Marine Science and Chemistry, Coastal Carolina University, P.O. Box 261954, Conway, South Carolina 29528-6054 WILLIAM M. LANDING Department of Oceanography, Florida State University, Tallahassee, Florida 32306-4320 GARY A. GILL Department of Marine Sciences, Texas A&M University, 5007 Avenue U, Galveston, Texas 77551 CURTIS D. POLLMAN Tetra Tech, Inc., 408 West University Avenue, Suite 301, Gainesville, Florida 32601 The primary goal of the Florida Atmospheric Mercury Study (FAMS) was to quantify the atmospheric deposition of Hg throughout Florida. Monthly integrated precipitation and weekly integrated particulate samples were collected at 10 sites in Florida for periods ranging from 2 to 5 yr. The monthly rainfall across the state and the concentrations of Hg in wet-only and bulk deposition increased by a factor of 2-3 during the summertime “wet season” (MayOctober). These parallel increases in rainfall amount and Hg concentration resulted in 5-8-fold increases in rainfall Hg deposition during the wet season. The annual volumeweighted Hg concentrations ranged from 14 ( 2 to 16 ( 2 ng/L across southern Florida, and the annual rainfall Hg fluxes ranged from 20 ( 3 to 23 ( 3 µg m-2 yr-1. The weekly integrated particulate Hg concentrations in southern Florida were low (4.9-9.3 pg/m3) and did not exhibit strong seasonal variability. Considering the pronounced seasonal pattern in rainfall Hg deposition, the relatively uniform summertime rainfall Hg concentrations, and the low concentrations of particulate Hg, we conclude that processes other than particulate Hg transport and scavenging govern rainfall Hg deposition in southern Florida. We hypothesize that long-range transport of reactive gaseous Hg (RGM) species coupled with strong convective thunderstorm activity during the summertime represents >50% of the Hg deposition in southern Florida. Model calculations indicate that local anthropogenic particulate Hg and RGM emissions account for 30-46% of the summertime rainfall Hg deposition across the southern Florida peninsula. Introduction The discovery of elevated levels of Hg (0.4-4.4 ppm) in large freshwater game fish from southern Florida (1) and the death, potentially attributed to Hg toxicosis, of one endangered * Corresponding author e-mail: jguentze@coastal.edu; phone: (843)349-2374; fax: (843)349-2545. 10.1021/es001523+ CCC: $20.00 Published on Web 01/26/2001 2001 American Chemical Society Florida panther (Felis concolor coryi) from a remote region of southern Florida (2) prompted State and Federal agencies to investigate the sources of Hg to Florida’s ecosystems. Previous studies have demonstrated the importance of atmospheric transport and deposition of particulate (aerosol) Hg as a mechanism for the delivery of Hg to remote and pristine ecosystems (3, 4). Mercury in precipitation results from the scavenging of aerosol Hg and reactive gaseous forms of Hg(II) (RGM). Elemental gaseous Hg has a very low solubility in water and must first become oxidized before it is efficiently scavenged by precipitation events. These various forms of Hg in the atmosphere originate from natural processes (25%) and anthropogenic activities (75%) (5). The relatively long atmospheric residence time for elemental gaseous Hg (1 yr) results in an elevated global atmospheric background of anthropogenic Hg (6). In highly urbanized and industrialized regions, the deposition of Hg can be strongly influenced by contributions of aerosol Hg and reactive gaseous Hg (RGM) from local sources. Hg deposition in rural regions is usually significantly lower than in urbanized areas because local anthropogenic emissions are attenuated, by deposition and dilution, as the distance from urban sources increases. This conceptual model has been invoked to describe the deposition of Hg in many regions (6-8). Determining the atmospheric loading of Hg to Florida was therefore a necessary first step toward understanding the processes that govern the cycling of Hg in Florida’s aquatic ecosystems. As a result, the Florida Atmospheric Mercury Study (FAMS) was initiated in the fall of 1992. The primary objective of the FAMS project was to quantify geographical and seasonal gradients in atmospheric Hg deposition across Florida. Other objectives of the study included determining whether subregional gradients in Hg deposition occurred and whether Hg deposition could be correlated with regions (“hotspots”) of alarmingly high Hg concentrations (1-4 ppm) in fish from Everglades Water Conservation Area WCA-3. The project included studying the partitioning between wet and dry deposition; investigating the speciation of Hg in precipitation, throughfall (9), and gaseous Hg (10); and identifying the possible sources of Hg using multiple chemical tracers (11, 12). This paper discusses the concentrations of Hg in aerosols and precipitation and the rates of rainfall Hg deposition at 10 locations in Florida and a site in Barbados. In addition, we propose a model to account for the sources of the elevated rainfall Hg deposition over the southern Florida peninsula. Two meteorological processes that are characteristic of the southern Florida peninsula during the “wet season” (May-October) are the strong synoptic southeast and easterly winds associated with the tropical North Atlantic trade winds and the formation of deep convective thunderstorm cells. The tall (12-16 km) convective thunderstorms are generated when moist air from the sea breeze is carried aloft by the hot air masses rising off the southern peninsula of Florida. In contrast to low altitude frontal storms, tall convective thunderstorms can scavenge particulate Hg and watersoluble RGM from the middle and upper troposphere. We propose that the southeasterly trade winds regularly resupply reactive gaseous Hg species to the atmosphere over the southern peninsula of Florida from May to October. As a result, the tall convective thunderstorms are exposed to a fresh atmospheric burden of “background” RGM on an almost daily basis during the summer months. We present arguments that anthropogenic sources of RGM in Dade and Broward Counties, primarily municipal solid waste and medical waste incinerators, supply less than half of the daily summertime VOL. 35, NO. 5, 2001 / ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY 9 863 FIGURE 1. Locations of the nine atmospheric sampling towers (LB, FM, FS, EG, TT, CK, AT, EN, and CV) and two ground-based sites (EGG and FL) used in the FAMS project. RGM burden in the southern Florida airshed. We estimate that a greater mass of RGM enters the airshed due to daily ventilation with background air containing scavengable RGM and aerosol Hg. Oxidation of gaseous elemental Hg within the airshed over southern Florida could supply an additional 8% of the daily RGM burden in the boundary layer. Experimental Methods Site Locations. The FAMS monitoring network consisted of 10 sites in Florida (Figure 1). The Caryville site of the Florida Acid Deposition Network (CV) and Lake Barco (LB) in the Katherine Ordway Reserve represented north and north central Florida, respectively. The sites in southern Florida were located at the Terry Park recreational complex in Ft. Myers (FM), the ranger’s compound of the Fakahatchee Strand State Preserve (FS), the Tamiami Trail Ranger Station (TT) of the Everglades National Park at “40-mile bend” on U.S. Highway 41, the Beard Research Center in the Everglades National Park (EG), the Andytown substation of Florida Power & Light (AT), the South Florida Water Management District Everglades Nutrient Removal Project (EN), and the state park on Little Crawl Key (CK). Each of these sites was equipped with a 15-m aluminum staircase tower with outboard sampling platforms (UpRight Inc.). The samples were collected on top of the towers to minimize the influence of birds and insects and locally generated dust and pollen (13, 14). Two ground-based sites were added to the network in 1995 (Figure 1). The EGG site was established in May 1995 to sample Hg in throughfall and was located under a 4-6-m stand of brazilian pepper trees (Schinus terebinthifolius) approximately 50 m from the EG tower. These trees have foliage year-round. The Ft. Lauderdale site (FL) rain sampler was positioned in July 1995 on a 1.5-m wooden sampling platform located in a grassy field at the University of Florida Institute of Food and Agricultural Sciences regional facility in the Ft. Lauderdale suburb of Davie, FL. This site is approximately 22 km east of the AT site, which borders the eastern edge of the Everglades Water Conservation Area WCA-3, and is less than 2 km from a municipal solid 864 9 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY / VOL. 35, NO. 5, 2001 waste incinerator. Samples were also collected atop the NSF-sponsored Atmosphere-Ocean Chemistry Experiment (AEROCE) sampling tower on remote, windward “Ragged Point” in Barbados (BS) (14). Sample Collection. The success of this project was dependent upon the use of rigorous sample collection protocols coupled with processing and analysis under “clean lab” conditions. In the clean lab at Florida State University, extensive detergent, solvent, and acid washing procedures were used to clean the sampling equipment (15-17). Thorough discussions of the QA/QC procedures, cleaning procedures, equipment design, and sampling methods have been published by Landing et al. (18), Guentzel et al. (15), Pollman et al. (19), Gill et al. (10), Landing et al. (16), and Gill and Fitzgerald (17). Monthly integrated bulk and wet-only deposition samples were collected at the 9 tower sites for periods ranging from 2 to 5 yr. Monthly integrated wet-only deposition samples were collected at the two ground-based sites (EGG and FL). Monthly integrated bulk deposition samples were collected on the Barbados (BS) tower. The FAMS bulk deposition collectors were fabricated using Teflon components, FEP Teflon receiving bottles, and polycarbonate funnels (6, 15, 16). Duplicate bulk deposition samplers were deployed at each site, and the upward-facing polycarbonate funnels were left uncovered for the entire month-long deployment period. Immediately before the samples were recovered, the funnels were each rinsed with two 70-mL aliquots of ultrapure water acidified with triple distilled sub-boiling quartz-distilled HCl (0.045 M 3×Q-HCl). Thus, the bulk deposition samples represent wet deposition plus any dry deposition that may have accumulated on the inner surface of the funnel (16). The wet deposition samples were collected using a modified Aerochem Metrics 301 wet/dry deposition sampler equipped with a polycarbonate roof, splash guard, Tefloncovered seal, and Teflon-coated arms (16). One 1-L polyethylene bottle (pH and major ions) and two 1-L FEP Teflon receiving bottles were nested inside the wet bucket and were attached to polycarbonate funnels using PTFE Teflon couplings. Rainfall amounts exceeding 27 cm/month were not collected due to the volume limitation of our receiving bottles. This loss amounted to less than 5% of the annual rainfall at 10 of the 12 sampling locations (Table 1). Excluding the few periods when the samples overfilled, the excellent agreement between the sample volumes and the rain gauge volumes indicates that the rain events were quantitatively collected over the course of the monthly deployment (sample/gauge ) 1.02 ( 0.01 SD; n ) 822; ref 16). Equipment blanks and field blanks for the 30-day deployment of bulk and wet deposition were negligible (<12%) when compared to the total mass of Hg in the samples (15, 16). The sampling and analytical methods were extensively tested and are free from significant contamination or loss of Hg created by the 30-day integration times and the design of the sampling equipment (15, 16). Variability for total Hg between co-located samples ranged from 1 to 5%. Intercomparison exercises with other laboratories have confirmed the accuracy of the sampling and analytical procedures used for total Hg analysis at FSU (15, 16, 20). Particulate (aerosol) Hg was collected at 40-60 L/min on 47 mm of 0.4-µm acid-cleaned polypropylene filters (MSI, Inc.) and integrated for 6 days out of each week (ThursdayTuesday). The open-faced polypropylene filter holders were mounted facing outward into free air under a Plexiglas rain shroud mounted on top of the tower. Field blank filters were placed in identical filter holders within the rain shrouds. No significant differences ((10%) were observed between particulate Hg samples collected for integration periods of 6 days vs summing six consecutive 24-h integrated samples (16). TABLE 1. Annual and Overall (1992-1996) Volume-Weighted Mean Concentrations and Fluxes of Hg for the FAMS Sampling Locationsa VOL. 35, NO. 5, 2001 / ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY 1993 rain (cm) [wet] (ng/L) [bulk] (ng/L) wet flux (µg m-2 yr-1) bulk flux (µg m-2 yr-1) 1994 rain (cm) [wet] (ng/L) [bulk] (ng/L) wet flux (µg m-2 yr-1) bulk flux (µg m-2 yr-1) 1995 rain (cm) [wet] (ng/L) [bulk] (ng/L) wet flux (µg m-2 yr-1) bulk flux (µg m-2 yr-1) 1996 rain (cm) [wet] (ng/L) [bulk] (ng/L) wet flux (µg m-2 yr-1) bulk flux (µg m-2 yr-1) averaged rain (cm) [wet] (ng/L) [bulk] (ng/L) wet flux (µg m-2 yr-1) bulk flux (µg m-2 yr-1) uncollected rain (%)e CV LB FM FS TTb 134 11.4 11.1 15.3 14.9 148 9.4 8.9 13.9 13.2 141 ( 10 10 ( 1 10 ( 3 14 ( 1 14 ( 1 0.6 106 12.4 13.4 13.1 14.2 137 13.8 13.9 18.9 19.0 123 12.1 10.9 14.9 13.4 113 11.1 10.3 12.5 11.6 123 ( 14 13 ( 2 12 ( 2 16 ( 3 15 ( 3 3.4 136 17.2 16.4 23.4 22.3 127 18.0 17.8 22.9 22.6 165 13.3 11.7 21.9 19.3 121 17.4 16.8 21.1 20.3 137 ( 10 16 ( 2 16 ( 2 22 ( 2 22 ( 2 1.4 135 15.4 14.5 20.8 19.6 144 18.8 16.9 27.1 24.3 213 12.9 11.8 27.5 25.1 131 14.9 14.4 19.5 18.9 156 ( 38 15 ( 3 14 ( 2 23 ( 3 22 ( 3 9.8 140 17.4 16.7 24.4 23.4 150 13.1 12.1 19.7 18.2 102 15.5 15.2 15.8 15.5 131 ( 21 15 ( 3 15 ( 3 20 ( 3 20 ( 3 4.9 ENc 131 15.6 15.2 20.4 19.9 149 14.7 14.4 21.9 21.5 140(43 15 ( 2 15 ( 2 21 ( 2 21 ( 2 0.0 AT 127 14.1 12.2 17.9 15.5 104 13.2 12.7 13.7 13.2 140 ( 43 14 ( 2 12 ( 2 20 ( 6 17 ( 5 4.6 FL 123 12.9 15.9 135(16 14 ( 1 19 ( 3 4.7 EG 177 13.8 12.9 24.4 22.8 167 14.1 12.9 23.5 21.5 114 13.3 12.3 15.2 14.0 148 ( 30 14 ( 2 13 ( 2 21 ( 3 20 ( 3 3.0 EGG 114 15.4 17.6 148 ( 30 15 ( 4 21 ( 3 1.3 CK 127 10.7 9.1 13.6 11.6 68 10.9 11.1 7.4 7.5 101 ( 30 11 ( 1 10 ( 3 11 ( 1 12 ( 3 5.7 BS 100 6.5 6.5 86 6.4 5.5 93 ( 10 6.4 ( 1 4.8 ( 1 3.8 a Annual values are reported when a complete calendar year was sampled. b The April 1995 data were substituted for April 1994 because tower damage precluded sampling. c The April 1996 data were substituted for April 1995 because tower damage precluded sampling. d Average annual values were calculated by volume-weighted averaging for 12-month periods from the onset of the site establishment. Errors were assessed by computing a series of 12-month averages starting in January, April, July, and October of each year and then propagated using standard techniques. e Uncollected rain signifies overfilling of the receiving bottles beyond 27 cm/month (see Figures 2-4); however, Hg fluxes were calculated using the Hg concentrations and the rain depths from the tipping-bucket rain gauge record. 9 865 Analytical Methods. The rain samples were acidified with 7.5 mL of 6 M 3×Q HCl (added prior to deployment) and 3 mL of 7.5 M 1×Q HNO3 (added after sample recovery) per liter of sample, hermetically sealed in the FEP Teflon bottles and digested in a low-wattage UV flux (730 µW/cm2; 254 nm) for 48 h (15). Subsamples (100-300 mL) were reduced with 25 mL of 1 M NaBH4 followed by gas-phase stripping and Hg amalgamation onto gold-coated quartz grains. The Hg was quantified using cold vapor atomic fluorescence (21, 22). The analytical detection limit, based on three times the standard deviation of the purge blank, was 0.05 ng/L for a sample volume of 200 mL. The aerosol samples were digested using polymer-jacketed PTFE Teflon microwave digestion bombs (Parr, Inc.). The total dissolution treatment uses a mixture of 6 M 3×Q HCl/ 15.9 M 1×Q HNO3/28.9 M Ultrex HF (J. T. Baker) (23). The digest was analyzed for total Hg using SnCl2 reduction and CVAFS (15). Using a typical air sample volume of 300 m3, the procedural detection limit was 1 pg/m3. Frequent digestion and analysis of NIST-2704 standard reference material (Buffalo River Sediment) yielded 97 ( 7% (n ) 34) recovery for total Hg. Results and Discussion Geographical and Seasonal Patterns of Hg in Precipitation. The monthly integrated rainfall volumes and wet-only Hg concentrations and fluxes for the nine Florida tower sites, the ground-based EGG and FL sites, and the Barbados AEROCE tower are shown in Figures 2-4. The annual volumeweighted mean rainfall Hg concentrations and fluxes are summarized in Table 1. The annual rainfall volumes across the southern Florida peninsula ranged from 102 to 213 cm, with an average of 70% of the rainfall occurring during the wet season (May-October). This rainfall pattern is generated by the almost daily occurrence of strong convective thunderstorms across southern Florida during the summer months. The concentrations of Hg in wet-only and bulk precipitation samples varied seasonally, with the concentrations being 2-3 times higher during the wet season months. The volume-weighted mean concentrations for the urban (FM, AT, FL, EN) and rural (FS, TT, EG, EGG) sites in southern Florida were very similar, while the northern (CV, LB) and marine sites (CK, BS) were significantly lower (Table 1). The monthly integrated bulk and wet deposition fluxes of Hg at all of the sites showed strong seasonal dependency, with 70-90% of the Hg deposition occurring during the summer. Both the rainfall volumes and rainfall Hg concentrations increased by factors of 2-3, resulting in a 5-8-fold increase in rainfall Hg deposition during the wet season (Figures 2-4; Table 1). The occasional high concentration samples collected during the dry season were associated with very low rainfall volumes (0.1-1.0 cm) and accounted for less than 10% of the annual rainfall Hg deposition. The annual volumeweighted Hg fluxes at the urban (FM, AT, FL, EN) and rural (FS, TT, EG) sites in southern Florida were not significantly different from each other, demonstrating that there was no significant east to west gradient in Hg deposition across the southern Florida peninsula (Table 1). The Hg fluxes from sites located in northern and central Florida are 20-30% lower and are similar to measurements from mid-continental (US) areas that receive low altitude frontal storms (3, 7). The marine sites (CK, BS) had the lowest Hg fluxes; similar to background marine fluxes reported by refs 24-26. This uniformity of Hg deposition across southern Florida is in stark contrast to what we have observed for other trace elements measured on the same samples (11, 12). The concentrations of V, Ni, Cu, Zn, and Pb at the urban sites (FM, AT) were 20-80% higher than at the rural sites (EG, FS, TT), with 4-fold higher concentrations found during the winter months. In addition, the concentrations of these 866 9 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY / VOL. 35, NO. 5, 2001 elements in bulk deposition samples were significantly greater (30-100%) than the concentrations in wet-only rain samples. These observations highlight the importance of urban aerosol emission sources for many of the trace elements, and emphasize how different their rainfall deposition patterns are from what we observed for Hg. Particulate Hg. The weekly integrated concentrations of particulate Hg were low and did not show obvious seasonality (Figures 2-4; Table 2). This contrasts with reports of particulate Hg measured in the northeastern and midwestern United States, where wintertime values were significantly higher than summertime values (27, 28). The average volumeweighted concentrations ranged from 2.0 to 9.3 pg/m3 (Table 2). The lowest values were at the CK site and were similar to remote marine measurements reported by Fitzgerald (24) and Lamborg (26). The highest average particulate Hg concentrations were observed at the urban FM site in 1994 and 1996, while the EN site had the highest annual average concentration in 1995 (Table 2). All of these values are lower than particulate Hg levels reported for rural areas of the midcontinental United States (27, 28). Previous studies illustrating the dominance of local pollution sources reported concentrations of particulate Hg ranging from 22 to 1230 pg/m3 (6, 29, 30). Indeed, samples of 24-h integrated particulate Hg at our urban FL site in August 1995 (21 ( 29 pg/m3; range 2-120 pg/m3; n ) 27; ref 16) were significantly higher than simultaneous measurements at our suburban AT site (6.5 ( 5.6; range 2-10 pg/m3; n ) 28; ref 16) and agreed well with measurements made two summers earlier in surrounding Broward County (20-120 pg/m3) by Dvonch et al. (31). These data demonstrate that while the levels of particulate Hg can be higher proximal to the urban areas of southern Florida, the combined effects of localized wet and dry deposition yield significantly lower levels of particulate Hg across the rural southern Everglades. The low concentrations and absence of strong seasonal variability in our particulate Hg measurements suggest that aerosols do not contribute significantly to the Hg observed in precipitation over southern Florida. Using our average particulate Hg concentrations and a fine aerosol deposition velocity of 0.1 cm/s (32), we estimate dry-deposition fluxes of particulate Hg ranging from 0.04 to 0.26 µg m-2 yr-1. Even if the deposition velocity and the particulate Hg concentrations combined to yield an order of magnitude increase, these fluxes are small as compared to the average observed rates of rainfall Hg deposition in Florida (11-23 µg m-2 yr-1; Table 1). Thus, while particle transport, dry deposition, and rainfall scavenging have been invoked in other studies to explain Hg concentrations in precipitation and geographical gradients in Hg deposition (3, 6, 7, 26, 29, 30, 33), these processes do not appear to significantly influence rainfall Hg deposition in southern Florida. In a brief report describing the first two years of the FAMS data, Guentzel et al. (15) showed that the wintertime rainfall Hg concentrations decreased significantly as the rainfall volume increased, while the summertime concentrations seemed to remain elevated regardless of the rainfall amount. For any rainfall species to exhibit a “washout effect”, the rate at which that species is supplied for rainfall scavenging must be lower than the rate at which it is actually scavenged. Our complete data set shows that the monthly integrated wintertime Hg concentrations do indeed exhibit the washout effect, as do the sodium and non-sea-salt sulfate concentrations (Figure 5). However, the summertime wet season Hg concentrations clearly do not exhibit the same washout trend and, in fact, had generally higher and more uniform Hg concentrations for any given rainfall amount relative to the wintertime samples. The data suggest that the nature of the scavengable Hg reservoir in the airshed over southern Florida is different between the winter dry season and the summer FIGURE 2. Time series of rainfall, rainfall Hg concentrations, and rainfall Hg deposition at the (A) Caryville, (B) Lake Barco, (C) Little Crawl Key, and (D) Barbados AEROCE atmospheric sampling tower sites. See Figure 1 for the site locations and Table 1 for annual summaries of the data from each site. Data gaps were due to lightning strikes, power surges, or tower damage from motor vehicles or severe storms. wet season. During the wet season, the reservoir of scavengable Hg is either much larger and/or is more rapidly replenished. In a separate study (9), we found that Hg concentrations in throughfall (the EGG site; Table 1) were similar to those in ambient rain (the EG site, Table 1), further supporting our conclusion that dry deposition of particulate Hg does not appear to be very significant in the Everglades region. Reactive Gaseous Mercury: An Important Source of Hg in Rainfall. The low concentrations of particulate Hg, the VOL. 35, NO. 5, 2001 / ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY 9 867 FIGURE 3. Time series of rainfall, rainfall Hg concentrations, and rainfall Hg deposition at the (A) Ft. Myers, (B) Fakahatchee Strand, (C) Tamiami Trail, and (D) Beard Research Center atmospheric sampling tower sites. See Figure 1 for the site locations and Table 1 for annual summaries of the data from each site. Data gaps were due to lightning strikes, power surges, or tower damage from motor vehicles or severe storms. absence of a significant geographical gradient in rainfall Hg, and the strong seasonal cycle of rainfall Hg deposition observed across the southern Florida peninsula suggest that processes other than aerosol transport and scavenging dominate wet deposition of Hg in this region. Moreover, as 868 9 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY / VOL. 35, NO. 5, 2001 discussed above, a large or rapidly replenished reservoir of scavengable Hg is required to produce the observed relationship between high amounts of rainfall and high Hg concentrations during the wet season. Gill et al. (10) and Guentzel et al. (15) argued that there must be a large FIGURE 4. Time series of rainfall, rainfall Hg concentrations, and rainfall Hg deposition at the (A) Everglades Nutrient Removal Project, (B) Andytown, and (C) Ft. Lauderdale (Davie). See Figure 1 for the site locations and Table 1 for annual summaries of the data from each site. Data gaps were due to lightning strikes, power surges, or tower damage from motor vehicles or severe storms. TABLE 2. Annual Average Particulate Hg Concentrations at FAMS Tower Sitesa particulate Hg (pg/m3) 1994 station Caryville Lake Barco Ft. Myers Fakahatchee Strand Tamiami Trail Everglades Nutrient Removal Project Andytown Beard Research Center Little Crawl Key a 1995 1996 overall site ID mean ( SD median mean ( SD median mean ( SD median mean ( SD median CV LB FM FS TT EN AT EG CK b 4.8 ( 2.3 7.9 ( 7.0 5.0 ( 2.2 4.6 ( 2.0 b 4.5 ( 2.0 4.1 ( 2.2 1.8 ( 1.3 4.3 5.9 4.9 4.5 4.2 3.8 1.4 5.0 ( 3.1 7.5 ( 8.6 7.0 ( 3.3 4.6 ( 1.9 4.0 ( 2.2 8.2 ( 4.4 5.5 ( 4.0 4.7 ( 2.9 1.6 ( 1.3 4.2 4.3 6.1 4.7 3.5 8.0 4.3 3.8 1.1 6.6 ( 3.6 5.1 ( 3.1 11.8 ( 7.3 6.2 ( 2.7 6.1 ( 3.6 10.2 ( 5.3 6.5 ( 3.5 5.3 ( 3.7 2.4 ( 1.4 Samples are integrated for 6 full days per week (Thursday-Tuesday). All concentrations are in pg/m3. contribution from highly reactive water-soluble gaseous Hg(II) species (RGM) to the rainfall deposition of Hg in Florida. They further pointed out that the relatively uniform rainfall Hg concentrations and fluxes across southern b 6.0 4.6 9.5 5.6 5.4 9.0 5.8 3.9 2.1 6.0 ( 3.5 5.7 ( 5.4 9.0 ( 6.3 5.2 ( 2.3 5.0 ( 2.8 9.3 ( 5.0 5.7 ( 3.6 4.9 ( 3.3 2.0 ( 1.4 5.2 4.4 7.3 5.1 4.5 8.5 4.9 4.0 1.6 Site not yet established. Florida required that the scavengable Hg coming from all sources into the airshed had to be relatively uniformly distributed on time scales of days to weeks during the wet season. VOL. 35, NO. 5, 2001 / ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY 9 869 FIGURE 5. Rainfall Hg concentration vs rainfall amount for monthly integrated samples from (A) urban sites, (B) rural sites, (C) rural sites (sodium), and (D) rural sites (non-sea-salt sulfate). The volume-weighted average Hg concentrations are provided for the wet and dry seasons. To a first approximation, the anthropogenic emission sources in Dade and Broward Counties can be thought of as RGM plumes originating at the base of an open window, along the southeastern coast of Florida, through which the trade winds blow during the wet season. These plumes are driven generally westward and are diluted by ambient background air. Tall convective thunderstorms, with a frequency on the order of 15-20 per month at each FAMS site, scavenge the RGM from the airshed and deposit it relatively evenly across the area covered by the FAMS network in southern Florida at a rate of 3-5 µg m-2 month-1 (g3 kg/day over the Florida peninsula south of the southern shore of Lake Okeechobee; 34 × 109 m2). These tall convective thunderstorms are reported to entrain approximately 60% of their air from the boundary layer and 40% from the free troposphere (34). Thus, we can estimate what fraction of the Hg in wet deposition results from the various RGM sources by evaluating the impact each source has on the daily inventory of RGM in the boundary layer and in the free troposphere over southern Florida. The means and standard deviations in the following estimates result from a Monte Carlo simulation (n ) 1000) where the various input parameters in each calculation are allowed to vary randomly over the quoted parameter range. There are relatively few quantified sources of RGM to the airshed over southern Florida. Dvonch et al. (35) estimated that the main anthropogenic RGM emission sources, municipal and medical waste incinerators and oil combustion sources, in the Miami/Ft. Lauderdale region emitted 2.5 ( 0.5 kg of RGM/day. In the Florida Pilot Mercury TMDL Study (36), all Hg emission sources in southern Florida cataloged 870 9 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY / VOL. 35, NO. 5, 2001 in the EPA emissions inventory were adjusted using the total Hg emissions values and RGM concentrations reported by Dvonch et al. (35), yielding a range of aerosol Hg plus RGM emission from 2.6 to 4.0 kg/day. During the wet season in southern Florida, the source for background air is primarily long-range transport due to the synoptic summertime trade winds. Accepting the global atmospheric Hg residence time of 1 yr (5), which requires a net oxidation rate of 0.3% per day, a boundary layer air mass that does not experience frequent scrubbing by rain events would be expected to gain on the order of 3-5 pg of RGM m-3 day-1. Trade wind transport also carries large quantities of African dust over southern Florida, demonstrating that a significant fraction of the air mass escapes scrubbing during the week-long transport time across the Atlantic (37). It is therefore reasonable to expect these same air masses to arrive over southern Florida with a burden of accumulated RGM plus aerosol Hg. Time series measurements of RGM at our remote CK site showed concentrations increasing from 5 pg/m3 in the winter to 30 pg/m3 in the summer (38). Measurements of RGM in the marine troposphere east of Miami (aircraft sampling between 800 and 2600 m) showed RGM values ranging from 50 to 340 pg/m3 during the late summer (39). These RGM measurements were all made using an ion-exchange filter pack technique (39) that has been shown to generally underestimate RGM concentrations relative to a mist chamber technique (32) or relative to KClcoated annular denuders (40). It would be clearly incorrect to assert that there should be no scavengable Hg in the background air masses crossing over southern Florida, and our data would suggest that the background boundary-layer RGM concentrations are at least 25 pg/m3. Whether local RGM sources in southern Florida or RGM associated with background air masses dominates the wet and dry deposition of RGM in southern Florida thus depends on the “replacement time” for RGM in the airshed over the southern peninsula: long-range RGM transport rate (g/day) ) [RGM]bkg (g/m3) × A (m2) × H (m) T (day) where T is the replacement (or ventilation) time, [RGM]bkg is the concentration in the background air, A is the area of the southern Florida peninsula south of Lake Okeechobee (34 × 109 m2), and H is the layer height (2600 m for the boundary layer and 9400 m for the free troposphere (41, 42). The observed [RGM]bkg of 25-35 pg/m3 and a replacement time of 1 day yields long-range RGM transport rates of 2-3 kg/day, comparable to the local emission rates. The same analysis can be applied to the free troposphere, where local RGM emissions would be a minor term. Because of the much deeper layer, the background [RGM] required to generate 2-3 kg/day is only 6-10 pg/m3 for a 1-day replacement time. Another source for RGM that is not related to local RGM emission is the homogeneous gas-phase oxidation of elemental Hg vapor by ozone. Using an average ozone concentration of 40-60 ppb (1.4 × 1018 atoms/m3), an elemental Hg vapor concentration of 1.5 ng/m3 (4.5 × 1012 atoms/m3), and a second-order rate constant of 2.6 × 10-21 m3 atom-1 day-1 (43) yields RGM production of 4-6 pg m-3 day-1. While ozone oxidation is not the only atmospheric reaction producing RGM (44), it is perhaps the one that is the best characterized. Oxidation of elemental gaseous Hg would therefore produce 0.43 ( 0.10 kg/day of RGM in the boundary layer over southern Florida given a production rate of 4-6 pg m-3 day-1, a boundary layer depth of 18003200 m, and an area of 34 × 109 m2. This represents 17 ( 5% of the local RGM emission. In the free troposphere, we assume that the average RGM production rate from the bimolecular ozone oxidation of elemental Hg would be reduced by 75% (due to the reduced pressure) to 1-1.5 pg m-3 day-1. RGM production by this mechanism in the free troposphere (260012 000 m over 34 × 109 m2) would then yield 0.38 ( 0.10 kg/day. Thunderstorm scavenging from the boundary layer during the summer wet season would therefore include roughly equal proportions of RGM from local sources (2.5 ( 0.5 kg/ day) and from long-range transport (2-3 kg/day) plus insitu oxidation of elemental Hg (0.43 kg/day). RGM scavenged from the free troposphere would come primarily from longrange transport (>2.5 kg/day) plus in-situ elemental Hg oxidation (0.38 kg/day). Local RGM sources would therefore account for approximately 30 ( 7% of the Hg in wet deposition (2.5 ( 0.5 kg/day out of 8.3 ( 0.9 kg/day total, assuming equivalent thunderstorm entrainment and RGM scavenging efficiency for the boundary layer and the free troposphere). Local sources would account for 46 ( 11% of the Hg in summertime rainfall (2.5 ( 0.5 kg/day out of 5.4 ( 0.7 kg/day total) if one made the extreme assumption that there is no RGM scavenging from the free troposphere. What fraction of the rainfall RGM deposition is expected to come from local sources over the course of a full year? From our data, we see that roughly 16% of the annual rainfall Hg deposition in southern Florida occurs during the November-April dry season. If we make an extreme assumption that long-range transport disappears completely while insitu elemental Hg oxidation matches the wet season value (0.43 ( 0.1 kg/day), then local RGM sources (2.5 ( 0.5 kg/ day) would account for 85 ( 23% of the daily boundary layer RGM supply during the dry season. Since winter (frontal) storms are less likely to scrub much of the free troposphere, we assign e14% of the annual rainfall Hg flux to local RGM sources during the dry season (85% local source supply times 16% of the annual rainfall Hg deposition). During the wet season, local RGM sources account for 25-39% of the annual rainfall Hg deposition (30-46% local source supply times 84% of the annual rainfall Hg deposition). These conclusions contrast sharply with those reached by Dvonch et al. (35, 45). During the SoFAMMS experiment, they collected over 300 24-h integrated rain samples in the Miami/Ft. Lauderdale area during August 1995 and analyzed them for Hg and a number of other trace elements. Using multi-variate statistical processing and detailed analysis of individual storm events, they concluded that local Hg emission sources had a significant impact on the rainfall Hg concentrations and deposition, accounting for 71-73% of the rainfall Hg deposition in their study domain. According to our calculations, local RGM sources could account for more than 70% of the wet deposition across southern Florida only by making the extreme assumptions that there is no RGM scavenging from the free troposphere and that the scavengable RGM plus aerosol Hg in the background boundary layer air is less than 5 pg/m3. Furthermore, the FAMS data from August 1995 show that the rainfall Hg concentrations and deposition at many of the other FAMS sites in southern Florida (Figures 2-4) were significantly higher than at the SoFAMMS Davie and Andytown sites (45). The Fakahatchee Strand site, over 60 km southwest of the Andytown site, had the highest rainfall Hg deposition of the FAMS sites during August 1995 (18 ng/L; 9.1 µg/m2). The CK site (19 ng/L; 4.37 µg/m2) is even farther away, over 150 km to the south-southwest of the Andytown site (15 ng/L; 4.35 µg/m2). One would expect rainfall washout of particulate Hg and RGM from local emission sources in the Miami/Ft. Lauderdale area to yield progressively lower (not higher) rainfall Hg concentrations and deposition as one moved away from the urban area. The MM5 meteorological model was used to generate forward trajectories from the urban emission sources and back trajectories from the CK site for every rain event during August 1995 at the CK site (46). Combining trajectories with daily rainfall amounts, Green et al. (46) concluded that less than 16% of the rainfall Hg collected at the CK site during August 1995 was associated with air masses that had passed near the RGM emission sources in the Miami/Ft. Lauderdale urban area. Our conclusions also conflict with model results from Bullock (47), who used the EPA Hg emissions inventory and the RELMAP model to predict Hg deposition across the continental United States. In southern Florida, the RELMAP model predicted a very strong east-to-west geographical gradient in rainfall Hg deposition, from >30 µg m-2 yr-1 near urban Miami/Ft. Lauderdale to <10 µg m-2 yr-1 in the remote Everglades (47). In contrast, our data shows nearly uniform rainfall Hg deposition across this region, including suburban Ft. Lauderdale to the east (the AT and FL sites; Table 1), and urban Ft. Myers to the west (the FM site). Most of the rainfall Hg deposition in the RELMAP model was due to locally emitted RGM because the model simulations did not include any RGM or particulate Hg in the background air masses (47, 48). As we concluded above and as Constantinou et al. (49) demonstrate in their plume dispersion/deposition model, the fraction of rainfall Hg that is due to RGM from any local source is completely governed by how much scavengable RGM and particulate Hg are brought into the model domain with the background air. There is further evidence that municipal and medical solid waste (MSW) incinerators in southern Florida are not the dominant RGM sources for rainfall Hg over southern Florida. Atkeson (50) reports that MSW incinerators in southern VOL. 35, NO. 5, 2001 / ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY 9 871 Florida have reduced their Hg emissions by almost a factor of 10 since 1994. Despite this dramatic reduction in Hg emission, the wet deposition of Hg at the EG site has not decreased significantly. Our data in Figure 4 shows Hg wet deposition of >17 µg m-2 yr-1 for an incomplete sampling year in 1993 at the EG site and then Hg wet deposition of 24, 24, and 15 µg m-2 yr-1 in 1994, 1995, and 1996, respectively. Data from the MDN network show Hg wet deposition at the EG site (FL-11) of 17 µg m-2 yr-1 in 1996, 27 µg m-2 yr-1 in 1997, 20 µg m-2 yr-1 in 1998, 17 µg m-2 yr-1 in 1999, and 17 µg m-2 yr-1 in 2000 (January-September) (51). It appears that the large reduction in local MSW incinerator Hg emissions has not resulted in a significant decrease in rainfall Hg concentrations or wet deposition of Hg at the EG site. In contrast, it was recently demonstrated that significant decreases in bulk Hg precipitation and deposition coincided with reductions in anthropogenic Hg emissions from a remote site in northern Wisconsin (52). Dry Deposition of RGM. What impact do these various RGM sources have on RGM dry deposition? Previous RGM modeling studies have noted the significance of rapid localized dry deposition, which depletes the RGM reservoir before wet deposition can occur farther downwind (47). If local emission sources of RGM (plus particulate Hg) are in fact responsible for less than half of the daily RGM supply in the summertime boundary layer, then those sources would account for less than half of the RGM dry deposition. During the winter, when long-range RGM transport is perhaps less important, local emission sources could dominate the supply of RGM to the boundary layer and may account for g85% of the wintertime dry deposition. Estimates of RGM dry deposition to Everglades vegetation (16 µg m-2 yr-1; ref 9) are slightly lower than our measured wet deposition rates (15-24 µg m-2 yr-1, Table 1). Extrapolating over the entire 34 × 109 m2 of southern Florida, dry deposition of RGM would come to 1.5 kg/day. Added to the 2.5-3 kg/day summertime wet deposition of Hg (total wet + dry g4 kg/day), it appears that the identified local RGM emission sources (2.5 ( 0.5 kg/day) are simply not adequate to supply all of the necessary RGM, even if one could somehow capture 100% of the emissions each day over the southern Florida peninsula. Implications for the Everglades Region. Our RGM source/ sink inventory described above is a first-order explanation of Hg deposition and the complicated summertime meteorology in southern Florida. Continued efforts to quantify background RGM in the boundary layer and the free troposphere; to quantify local emission sources; and to model Hg emission, transport, and scavenging will further explain and reconcile the FAMS and SoFAMMS data. Lagrangian deposition models (47, 48) and statistical source apportionment models (35) that aspire to explain the deposition of Hg in southern Florida should be able to simulate the strong seasonality we demonstrate with the FAMS rainfall Hg deposition data as well as the uniformity in Hg deposition across the entire southern Florida peninsula. Such modeling efforts must include the impacts of RGM and particulate Hg in background air. The contrast between uniform Hg deposition and geographical “hot spots” in fish Hg concentrations from the Everglades region further suggests that aquatic/terrestrial Hg cycling processes, rather than atmospheric source strength, are responsible for the hot spots. Ecosystem Hg cycling models for the Everglades should be structured to simulate the effects of the summertime pulses of reactive Hg in rainfall. Finally, it is important to recall that 60-70% of the Hg in the modern global atmosphere results from anthropogenic industrial activities (5). From our analysis of the data, we conclude that significant reduction in rainfall Hg deposition 872 9 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY / VOL. 35, NO. 5, 2001 over the Florida Everglades will likely require reductions in local and global Hg emissions. Acknowledgments This project was supported financially by grants from the Florida Department of Environmental Protection, Florida Power and Light, the Electric Power Research Institute, the South Florida Water Management District, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, and the Florida Electric Power Coordinating Group. The authors’ conclusions do not imply endorsement by these funding agencies. We thank the Florida Park Service, the National Park Service, the Keys Marine Laboratory, the Ordway Preserve, and Ken Larson of the Broward County Air Monitoring Program for providing logistical support. We gratefully recognize the invaluable assistance provided by the graduate students and support personnel employed by FSU, Texas A&M, and KBN Engineering. We specifically acknowledge the following: John Cooksey, Laurel Buttermore, Geoffrey Schaefer, Johan Schijf, Jerome J. Perry Jr., Scott Sigler, Stephanie Smith-Moore, Jill Brandenburger, Dave Oliff, Jim Winnie, Paul Ruscher, Melody Owens, Matt Green, Ron Lehman, Dave Bare, Mike Arrants, John and Gayle Swanson, Cornelius Shea, and the NSF/ AEROCE Program. Literature Cited (1) Lange, T. Florida Game and Freshwater Fish Commission, personal communication. (2) Jordan, D. Endangered Species Tech. Bull. 1990, XV (2). (3) Sorenson, J. A.; Glass, G. E.; Schmidt, K. W.; Huber, J. K.; Rapp, G. R., Jr. Environ. Sci. Technol. 1990, 24, 1716-1727. (4) Fitzgerald, W. F.; Mason, R. P.; Vandal, G. M. Water Air Soil Pollut. 1990, 56, 745-768. (5) Mason, R. P.; Fitzgerald, W. F.; Morel, F. M. M. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 1994, 58, 3191. (6) Iverfeldt, A. Water Air Soil Pollut. 1991, 56, 251-263. (7) Sorenson, J. A.; Glass, G. A.; Schmidt; K. W. Environ. Sci. Technol. 1994, 28, 2025-2032. (8) Jensen A.; Iverfeldt, A. In Mercury Pollution: Integration and Synthesis; Huckabee, J. W., Watras, C. J., Eds.; Lewis Publishers: Boca Raton, FL, 1994; pp 221-229. (9) Guentzel, J. L.; Landing, W. M.; Gill, G. A.; Pollman, C. D. Sci Total Environ. 1998, 213, 43-51. (10) Gill, G. A.; Guentzel, J. L.; Landing, W. M.; Pollman, C. D. Water Air Soil Pollut. 1995, 80, 235-244. (11) Landing, W. M.; Perry, J. J., Jr.; Guentzel, J. L.; Gill, G. A.; Pollman, C. D. Water Air Soil Pollut. 1995, 80, 343-352. (12) Perry, J. J., Jr.; Landing, W. M.; Guentzel, J. L.; Gill, G. A.; Pollman, C. D. Abstract submitted to the Fourth International Conference on Mercury as a Global Pollutant, Hamburg, Germany, August 4-8, 1996. (13) Duce, R. A. Chemical Oceanography 10; Academic Press: London, 1989; pp 1-14. (14) Savoie, D. L.; Prospero, J. M.; Saltzmann, E. S. J. Geophys. Res. 1989, 94, 5069-5080. (15) Guentzel, J. L.; Landing, W. M.; Gill, G. A.; Pollman, C. D. Water Air Soil Pollut. 1995, 80, 393-402. (16) Landing, W. M.; Guentzel, J. L.; Gill, G. A.; Pollman, C. D. Atmos. Environ. 1998, 32, 909-918. (17) Gill, G. A.; Fitzgerald, W. F. Mar. Chem. 1987, 20, 227-243. (18) Landing, W. M.; Guentzel, J. L.; Gill, G. A.; Pollman, C. D.; Bare, D. A. Report to the Florida Department of Environmental Protection, Tallahassee, FL, 1993 (19) Pollman, C.; Gill, G.; Landing, W.; Guentzel J.; Bare, D.; Porcella, D.; Zillioux, E.; Atkeson, T. Water Air Soil Pollut. 1995, 80, 285290. (20) Bloom, N. S.; Horvat, M. A.; Watras C. J. Water Air Soil Pollut. 1995, 80, 1257-1268. (21) Fitzgerald, W. F.; Gill, G. A. Anal. Chem. 1979, 51, 1714-1720. (22) Gill, G. A.; Bruland, K. W. Environ. Sci. Technol. 1990, 24, 13921400. (23) Eggimann, D. W.; Betzer, P. R. Anal. Chem. 1974, 48, 886-890. (24) Fitzgerald, W. F. Chemical Oceanography 10; Academic Press: London, 1989; pp 152-180. (25) Gill, G. A.; Fitzgerald, W. F. Global Biogeochem. Cycles 1987, 1, 199-213. (26) Lamborg, C. H.; Rolfhus, K. R.; Fitzgerald, W. F.; Kim, G. DeepSea Res. II 1999, 46, 957-977. (27) Burke, J.; Hoyer, M.; Keeler, G.; Scherbatskoy, T. Water Air Soil Pollut. 1995, 80, 353-362. (28) Keeler, G. J.; Glinsorn, G.; Pirrone, N. Water Air Soil Pollut. 1995, 80, 159-168. (29) Keeler, G. J.; Hoyer, M. E.; Lamborg, C. H. In Mercury Pollution: Integration and Synthesis; Huckabee, J. W., Watras, C. J., Eds.; Lewis Publishers: Boca Raton, FL, 1994; pp 231-241. (30) Lamborg, C. H.; Fitzgerald, W. F.; Vandal, G. M.; Rolfhus, K. R. Water Air Soil Pollut. 1995, 80, 189-198. (31) Dvonch, J. T.; Vette, A. F.; Keeler, G. J.; Evans, G.; Stevens, R. Water Air Soil Pollut. 1995, 80, 169-178. (32) Lindberg, S. E.; Stratton, W. J. Environ. Sci. Technol. 1998, 32, 49-57. (33) Hoyer, M.; Burke, J.; Keeler, G. J. Water Air Soil Pollut. 1995, 80, 199-208. (34) Petersen, G.; Munthe, J.; Pleijel, K.; Bloxam, R.; Kumar, A. V. Atmos. Environ. 1998, 32, 829-843. (35) Dvonch, J. T.; Graney, J. R.; Keeler, G. J.; Stevens, R. K. Environ. Sci. Technol. 1999, 33, 4522-4527. (36) Florida Department of Environmental Protection, Florida Pilot Mercury TMDL Study (Draft), 2000, http://www.dep.state.fl.us// labs/hg/docs/tmdldraft/. (37) Carlson, T. N.; Prospero, J. M. J. Appl. Meteorol. 1972, 11, 283297. (38) Gill, G., Unpublished data. (39) Prestbo, E. Mercury Speciation in the Boundary Layer and Free Troposphere Advected to South Florida: Phase I-Reconnaissance; Report Submitted to the Florida Department of Environmental Protection, Tallahassee, FL, 1996. (40) Sheu, G.-R.; Mason, R. P. Environ. Sci. Technol. (submitted for publication). (41) Kara, A. B.; Ruscher, P. H.; Elsner, J. B. Weather Forcasting 1998, 13, 921-933. (42) Ruscher, P. Department of Meteorology, Florida State University, personal communication. (43) Hall, B. Water Air Soil Pollut. 1995, 80, 301-315. (44) Seigneur, C.; Wrobel, J.; Constantinou, E. Environ. Sci. Technol. 1994, 28, 1589-1597. (45) Dvonch, J. T.; Graney, J. R.; Marsik, F. J.; Keeler, G. J.; Stevens, R. K. Sci. Total Environ. 1998, 213, 95-108. (46) Green, M. Masters Thesis, Department of Meteorology, Florida State University, 1998; 61 pp. (47) Bullock, O. R.; Brehme, K. A.; Mapp, G. R. Sci. Total Environ. 1998, 213, pp 1-12. (48) Bullock, O. R. In Mercury Study Report to Congress; U.S. EPA: Washington, DC, 1997; 5-1-5-31. (49) Constantinou, E.; Wu, X. A.; Seignur, C. Water, Air, Soil Pollut. 1995, 80, 325-335. (50) Atkeson, T. Florida Department of Environmental Protection, personal communication. (51) National Atmospheric Deposition Program (NRSP-3)/Mercury Deposition Network. NADP Program Office, Illinois State Water Survey, 2204 Griffith Drive, Champaign, IL 61820, 2000. (52) Watras, C. J.; Morrison, K. A.; Hudson, R. J. M.; Frost, T. M.; Kratz, T. K. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2000, 34, 4051-4057. Received for review July 26, 2000. Revised manuscript received December 4, 2000. Accepted December 5, 2000. ES001523+ VOL. 35, NO. 5, 2001 / ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY 9 873
© Copyright 2025 Paperzz